Okay so I am not affilitated with these guys in any way. I went and bought the Strut Pro bearing tool.
Fist off it is a heavy unit. It is big too. See size of apparatus with a nice soda pop bottle in the view for comparison.
They recently started shipping a blank plate for using the bearing removal tool as a propeller removal tool. First I removed the cotter key, then I removed the castelated nut. I did not get a locking nut with this boat. I turned the nut over so the flat side of the nut would take the load of the prop removal plate instead of either the castle-cut end of the nut, or the end of the threaded shaft. Tightening the tool had the prop off in nothing flat.
The next step is to get the bearing out. You use two hardened steel round sleeves held onto the forward portion of the prop shaft with velcro strap in front of the strut. Then a u-shaped collet with a 1" opening is tightened up against the sleeves. On the aft end of the tool is a larger u-shaped collet that is just larger than the 1.25" OD of the bearing. It is possible to slide the new bearing onto the shaft partially to help you line up the larger aft collet so that it clears the OD of the bearing coming out. On a Catalina 27 you CANNOT hang the device over the shaft; you have to manually suspend it while tightening up the rods enough to hold it in place. Note how little rooom there is between the hull and the back of the tool, (forward of the strut on the boat). Once you are snugged up, remove the new bearing you have been using to align the tool so you don't damage the new bearing.
Begin tightening the threaded rods, (BIG threaded rods) spinning each one equally to keep the collets as parallel as you can. The first few cranks gave me nothing and then BAM a loud pop, louder than when the prop gave way. It was at this point I decided to apply a litle heat. I have a hot air gun I use sometimes to solder electrical connections; it will melt a pool of solder in a #2 AWG lug in short order, yet it takes longer to toast a wire insulation jacket than a torch does, so the heat gun is really nice. With a good heating of the strut the bearing came out easily. Know easily is relative; I was still wrenching for about 30 minutes, maintaining heat and alternating sides as I went. It is a workout.
Once the old bearing is out, you flip the collets end-for end, placing the 1" u-shaped collet aft, and the 1.25" u-shaped collet forward. This is where life gets tricky. As you can see, I got the bearing quite a ways in before it stopped. I know that had I gone and read Maine Sail's article about using soap as a lubricant, I probably would not have spent another $60.00 for a new bearing today....
That being said, there is a torsion that you apply to the two bolts tightening the thing up, and it is proper to stop and check your alignment as necessary, in hindsight. This is something I did not do. The bite on the bearing happened when before I got the smaller 1" u-shaped collet to the straight-shaft section of the shaft. The collet pushing the bearing slipped sideways and started chewing the bearing up. Had it been a closed collet with a 1 clearance hole in the middle, I think the chances of that happening would be less. SO, today I went to my Fastenall store and piched up some HEAVY thru-hardened zink coated washers. I got three so I could build a good stack up. My theory is that with a closed round hole instead of a u-shaped hole I will apply more even pressure to the bearing, with less chance of slipping, biting or getting sideways. I also got a bar of Ivory to lube up the OD of the bearing, and I bought some Ivory dish soap to lube up the shaft and ID of the strut.
Anyway, here are the pics. Take 2 will certainly be after the fourth. I will let you guys know how it goes.