While cruising we either met or heard all the above about couples and their cruise/not cruise choice. The most amusing was the "Y" girl. An older gent would be on an island and his "Y" girl would fly to meet him. It would go well until the "Y" questions came up. Why can't we do something different, why can't you leave the islands, why, why why? He'd send her off on the next plane.I am a DAV having foot damage that will only get worse with age. We even discussed that this was our time since lantern my feet would become an issue.
How do you just stop over night after devoting the past 8 years to preparing, searching, educating yourself, building a future life cruising, and then STOP?
It doesn't get easier if the land-based friends are negative on the lifestyle. Peer pressure among women is very intense so having cruising friends should help, even if you can only follow their travels for a year or two. Make a contingency plan. Maybe you cruise a smaller boat and she meets you along the way. Maybe a motor sailor so it's a bit easier on you. Plenty of options if you think it through. I told mine I would look for crew if she wasn't interested. We did 8 months together this last trip and it had ups and downs so we're taking one winter to reflect (I call it freezing my a$$).
Best of luck and if you put your foot down, use the good one.
All U Get