There is much to consider:
*Sailing performance
*Cruising ability
*Construction and groundings
.. that is where I land...
Main sail (as usual) did a very throughout analysis. The O.P. needs to consider his sailing ground. Main Sail's analysis was based on where HE sails and how he likes to use his boat. Curious Sailor (the O.P.) sails in Florida .... I don't think granite ledges and freezing ballast are in Curious' future.... and like main sail.... shoal-ish is probably a good compromise for Florida.