It's much more clean than a gnarly old knot.
There is another area of thought regarding halyard termination at a shackle.
While the eye splice onto a shackle is an option, this can contribute to a couple of issues.
- jambs of the shackle against the sheave breaking down the sheave edges as the sail is hoisted to the mast head with the shackle and up against the sheave
- Poor eye splice construction with a increase of the line diameter at the splice. The larger line is hauled up tight against the mast head /sheave getting stuck or wearing down the splice as the halyard is tightened into the sheave
Just to name two.
A proper halyard hitch knot around a mainsail shackle stops both of these issues. The halyard hitch is compact so does not interfere with raising the sail to the correct height. The size of the knot is larger diameter than the sheave and masthead opening protection for the sheave. Because the knot is visible to the owner when the knot shows signs of wear/age knot can be removed and a new knot quickly tied shortening the halyard by only 4-6 inches.
How to tie the halyard hitch knot.
A very compact knot used to join a halyard line to a shackle. The Halyard Hitch is extremely compact which makes it an admirable choice for a halyard.
www.animatedknots.com
Consider this option.