How to prevent mildew during winter

Feb 16, 2021
548
Hunter Legend 35.5 Bellingham
I leave town for winter, and the past few years have fought mildew in the v berth and aft cabin. I leave a thermostat controlled heater on (Caframo True North), leave all my lockers open and remove all bedding, leaving cushions loosely positioned for circulation. I have left the v berth hatch and gate port lights cracked for circulation as well.
I’m thinking of adding a peltier dehumidifier to the mix (draining into the head sink, which drains through an above the waterline thru hull), and closing the hatch and port lights to keep humid air from entering (assuming the dehumidifier does its job). I’m also thinking of adding a fan to both the aft cabin and v berth to aid with circulation. As I’m gone for several months in the winter, I’m unable to regularly check on my boat. My concerns are fire risk of running these nonstop, unit failure, as well as excessive power draw/cost.
Any thoughts/input on best practices in this regard?

Update - I should have also mentioned that the boat lives at its slip in Bellingham Washington.
 
Last edited:

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
24,937
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
I’ve used a dehumidifier for a couple of seasons now. It had worked well. I set up a drain hose to the boat exterior. Last year when there was a deep freeze, ice formed in the hose and the unit shut down. The dehumidifier works well until the temperature drops to freezing. Then it is of no value. With the temperature dropping I’m planning to shut down the unit til spring.
 
Jan 1, 2006
8,185
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
I'm surprised that leaving a heater or dehumidifier running unattended would be tolerated by a marina (OP didn't say his boat is in a marina or boatyard). Maybe practices are different in the PNW?
 
Jan 4, 2006
7,870
Hunter 310 West Vancouver, B.C.
I'm in you're backyard and vice versa and not a trace of high humidity or mildew up here. No sources of water vapour either (that I've found) including leaving the toilet seat down. Bilge is bone dry with nothing but dust and cobwebs down there. I think bilges are a big source if wet.

Ventilation, ventilation. ventilation, ventilation.
 
Apr 8, 2010
2,258
Ericson Yachts Olson 34 28400 Portland OR
Ventilation is one key thing. I leave the cabintop vents open and hatches on "vent" position. I have added vents to all settee fronts, and every winter we take all the cushions home until spring. No smells or mildew.
About every 5th season we do wipe down the interior hull surfaces with some soap/bleach and damp rags, also. Well, the parts we can reach fairly easily...

With a keel-stepped spar, I do have to dry out the bilge once a week in winter storm season, also.
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,542
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Ventilation and heat. shemandr's caution is well placed, however I never left the heater on more than halfway unless I was there. A 600 to 900 watt load on a 1500 watt circuit should not be in issue for continuous load, assuming you have confirmed that your boat wiring is correct and done properly. Without heat it rains inside: cold 32F deck with snow over 47F boat in water. The fan is a good idea if you have areas that get issues recurringly. Don't forget to clean up before winter.

I'm surprised that leaving a heater or dehumidifier running unattended would be tolerated by a marina (OP didn't say his boat is in a marina or boatyard). Maybe practices are different in the PNW?
 
Mar 26, 2011
4,063
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
Local knowledge helps. There are many helpful people here, but each has a different experience.
  • Climate. Lakes vs. PNF vs. Florida.
  • Boat. Wet bilge vs. dry bilge, for example (yeah, I've heard the lectures--it is not always possible). Different material, hull liners, etc.
  • Different standards for mildew.
  • Perhaps only one experience. They have done it one way but have not tried other ways.
  • Different marina policies.
  • Do they spend time on the boat in the winter? (this adds humidity)
Dehumidifiers. You do NOT want a compressor-based unit. They will ice in the winter (below about 55F) and are more prone to overheating., Moreover, they are just more than you need. Look for a small Peltier effect or regenerating desiccant type. There is no need to remove more than a pint in a day. Low electrical draw and thus, minimal risk.

Locate it in a safe location. I like the stovetop (nothing can burn). The drain should go overboard (sink if high enough, or the cockpit).

In a drier climate, good ventilation is sufficient. Not in the water, in cold climates, where the air and water temperatures can be very different. Condensation can be excessive.

Consider insulating windows and other condensation-prone areas.

I'm not comfortable with heaters. Also, what is important is the differencial between inside and outside, not the temperature, and there must be some air exchange, or you are just creating a hot house (heat ONLY lowers the humidity IF there is air exchange).

---

My experience on the Chesapeake Bay for 40 years, with fabric liners, is that a small Peltier effect dehumidifier and NO heat is the best combination. Pillows stay fresh. My last boat had dust in the bilge, this one is wet.
 
Feb 10, 2004
4,255
Hunter 40.5 Warwick, RI
See my post #5 below from a few years ago. I have been using this technique for over 25 years now with pure success. The cost and labor are minimal. No power consumption, no risk of fire. If you normally have a wet bilge, be sure to vacuum our all of the water. Keep the hatches closed so you don't introduce more moisture.

 
  • Like
Likes: Sail22Capri22

JBP-PA

.
Apr 29, 2022
836
Jeanneau Tonic 23 Erie, PA
I'm surprised that leaving a heater or dehumidifier running unattended would be tolerated by a marina (OP didn't say his boat is in a marina or boatyard). Maybe practices are different in the PNW?
I've been tempted to try the Caframo or Davis storage heaters. They are low wattage heaters, under 100W, intended to be left on all winter.


 
Mar 26, 2011
4,063
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
Consider:
  • In Maine, in the early spring you can have snow on the roof and warm air. If you ventilate, the roof will literally rain.
  • On the Chesapeake, in the early spring, you can have 45F water and 80F humid air. Or 60F humid air with ice still on the water. If you ventilate, the hull sweats in running streams. In fact, it is not good to ventilate the bilge in the early spring; it will just get wetter and wetter. Seal it up.
  • On the hard, the temperatures inside and out are closer. Ventilation alone has a much better chance, unless it is a high-snow area. However, there are VERY few places that will let you run power on the hard. Insurance and local fire codes.
The opposite can happen in the fall, though not so extreme.

No one answer.
 
Mar 26, 2011
4,063
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
I've been tempted to try the Caframo or Davis storage heaters. They are low wattage heaters, under 100W, intended to be left on all winter.


You have to either button it up TIGHT and use a dehumidifier/Damprid, or use heat. You can NOT use both and seal it up, and expect to dry the cabin; heat only dries IF there is air exchange (research how humidity works). Ventilation is the other option; effectiveness relies on the boat being truly, 100% leak-tight, and the boat being on the hard.

I would not expect too much from Nosguard on a boat. They are sized for cars. Also, the chlorine will slightly degrade everything in the boat; that is how chlorine works. (Yes, I tested them for Practical Sailor--you may be able to search the article)
 
  • Like
Likes: JBP-PA
Feb 16, 2021
548
Hunter Legend 35.5 Bellingham
See my post #5 below from a few years ago. I have been using this technique for over 25 years now with pure success. The cost and labor are minimal. No power consumption, no risk of fire. If you normally have a wet bilge, be sure to vacuum our all of the water. Keep the hatches closed so you don't introduce more moisture.

I leave my boat at its slip for the winter, I could try some in a colander over the head sink (drain is above the water line), but I suppose I would come back to a corroded SS sink?
 
Feb 16, 2021
548
Hunter Legend 35.5 Bellingham
I've had a very good experience with 2 Davis Dryr 1000's..... research them
I like that there’s no fan to fail. But I don’t like that there’s no fan to circulate the air. If I put one forward and one aft does that seem adequate? My thoughts now are just that with my caframo true north to keep things above freezing. Aren’t fans necessary for air circulation though?
 
Last edited:
Jan 19, 2010
1,401
Catalina 34 Casco Bay
I like that there’s no fan to fail. But I don’t like that there’s no fan to circulate the air. If I put one forward and one aft does that seem adequate? My thoughts now are just that with my caframo true north to keep things above freezing. Aren’t fans necessary for air circulation though?
we have aC-34 with lots of volume. 2 work. One in the aft cabin hatchway and the other close to the v-berth hatchway. Each is good for 1000 cu ft.
No fan is correct.. The heated and dry air rises, cools and re-circulates . It's spontaneous heat flow as in the 2nd law of thermodynamics .
 
Feb 16, 2021
548
Hunter Legend 35.5 Bellingham
we have aC-34 with lots of volume. 2 work. One in the aft cabin hatchway and the other close to the v-berth hatchway. Each is good for 1000 cu ft.
No fan is correct.. The heated and dry air rises, cools and re-circulates . It's spontaneous heat flow as in the 2nd law of thermodynamics .
I assume you close all hatches and port lights and leave the boat at your slip? Are you in the PNW?
 
Oct 6, 2007
1,184
Hunter H30 1982 Chicago IL
The answers depend on climate which varies widely across North America, storage in the water or on the hard, covered or uncovered, etc.

My approach to preventing condensation and mildew during winter storage (Shrink wrapped and on the hard.) in Chicago is a simultaneous combination of both passive ventilation and desiccant humidity reduction. No unattended electric heaters, dehumidifiers or fans.

For passive ventilation; the galley and lavatory sink seacocks are left open, the head portlite is opened about an inch after the shrink wrap goes on, and there are two small louvered vents in the aft coaming. The shrink wrap gets at least four plastic vent inserts. For desiccant humidity reduction; eight DampRid buckets are deployed in the cabin with all lockers emptied and propped open. The desiccant pulls moisture out of the air during rainy or humid weather, mostly in the spring and late fall. Desiccant really does nothing during freezing weather and the humidity is low then anyway. During cold winter weather, the air that enters the cabin is extremely dry.

When desiccant is not drying the cabin, passive ventilation is, and vice versa. This two pronged approach has worked for me for nearly two decades, but I wouldn’t recommend it outside of the Great Lakes and the upper mid-west.
 
Last edited:
Mar 26, 2011
4,063
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
The answers depend on climate which varies widely across North America, storage in the water or on the hard, covered or uncovered, etc.

My approach to preventing condensation and mildew during winter storage (Shrink wrapped and on the hard.) in Chicago is a simultaneous combination of both passive ventilation and desiccant humidity reduction. No unattended electric heaters, dehumidifiers or fans.

For passive ventilation, the galley and head sink seacocks are left open, the head portlite is opened about an inch after the shrink wrap goes on, and there are two small louvered vents in the aft coaming. The shrink wrap gets at least four plastic vent inserts. For desiccant humidity reduction, eight DampRid buckets are deployed in the cabin with all lockers emptied and propped open. The desiccant pulls moisture out of the air during rainy or humid weather, mostly in the spring and late fall. Desiccant really does nothing during freezing weather, but the humidity is low then anyway. During cold winter weather, the air that enters the cabin is extremely dry.

When desiccant is not drying the cabin, passive ventilation is, and vice versa. This two pronged approach has worked for me for nearly two decades, but I wouldn’t recommend it outside of the Great Lakes and the upper mid-west.
Venting and desiccant... I think the math does not work as you think. Is there still desiccant in the spring, when you open the boat? But it works because you are not in a damp climate, compared to coastal areas with ocean-warmed water. In boats with wet bilges and warm water, the desiccant would only last a few weeks or a month. Yup, tested that. Basically, you are drying the great outdoors, if there are vents.

Relative humidity in Seattle is about 85-90% through the winter. Very high. Think fog inside the boat some nights! Different. It is also considerably warmer, meaning the air holds more water at a given RH.

Coastal MD and coastal Maine are about 80% RH. Chicago is colder and about 75% RH.

Also, mold does not grow when it is sub-freezing. Nothing does. IME, it is a spring thing.

Also, the OP keeps his boat in the water. That makes a BIG difference, since any water in the bilge will condense in the cold cabin(the water is considerably warmer than the air).

Complicated.