Take the cover off of the water pump and check the impeller vanes. Are they perfectly flush with the pump housing or do they protrude slightly? On our Onan, with the correct impeller, the vanes protruded slightly. The blue impeller that I mentioned in my earlier post did not. The very thin gasket made up some of the difference between the vanes and the cover. If there is any amount of space between the vanes and the cover, it could be enough to prevent a good prime, which happened with our Onan. Also, be sure to test the shaft seal. I did my test by plugging one of pump ports and blowing hard into the other. No leaky.