Tiller Extension for a C22

Status
Not open for further replies.
May 13, 2012
37
mac mac ca
Something doesn't add up here. Near broaching in 15 knot winds with gusts to what, maybe 20? The Catalina 22 is not that tender and this should not be happening with a 110 jib. The C-22 is not comparable to an unballasted daysailer or a catamaran, no way.

Please forgive the remedial question. Do you have a swing keel or fixed? If swing, is it lowered? Are you SURE it's lowered and not stuck in the retracted position?

BTW, don't worry about the close-hulled thing, we knew what you meant. There are many members here with considerable experience who are pretty brutal with the traditional vernacular but we somehow manage just fine.
I know it doesn't add up but that's the deal. And it's a fixed keel. And yes it's 15 to 16 knot steady with pretty constant 20 to 22 gusts. Every gust will almost lay the boat down.
 
May 13, 2012
37
mac mac ca
Is this happening when you're sailing along at 4+ knots, or is after executing a tack and your speed has dropped considerably? I find that if I get too sloppy in the tack, and get hit by a gust, I almost put the rails in the water. The trick for me is not to let her head up, but to pull hard, holding my heading, until the speed gets back up.

My boat does not play well with gusts when I'm moving at less than 2.5 kts. I think the lift produced by the keel helps fight heeling the faster you're going. That's why I'll fall off a bit if necessary to pick up speed prior to tacking. I hope this makes sense,
It only happens when I'm close hauled or nearly close hauled and sailing along at 4 or more like 5+ knots in 15+ winds and/or in 20+ gusts.
 
May 13, 2012
37
mac mac ca
How old are the sails?
They're original 71's but still crisp with no stains, damage or tears. Apparently the boat sat unused for 20 years in storage with the sails bagged in the garage.
 
May 13, 2012
37
mac mac ca
I've decided to go with the tiller extension. The stock tiller is about 8 to 10 inches to short even if I'm not heeling. I always feel that I'm reaching and stretching. Its horribly uncomfortable. I can never sit back and relax. Maybe I have short arms. I will let you know how it turns out.
 
Feb 26, 2004
22,909
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
With your short arms, perhaps the extender will help, but if you're rockin' and rollin' as you describe, I would find it much too dangerous to sit on the coaming and try to steer.

When we had our C22, we had 2 seasons: summer on the lake and winters on San Francisco Bay. Sometimes we'd get up to the lake well after Memorial Day, so ended up sometimes in the BIG winds here on the Bay.

I would use the extender when things were calm and comfortable. Once the winds picked up, regardless of where the boat was (lake or Bay, and the lake could blow hard, too), I'd want to be inside the boat not on the edges.

Given your descriptions of your experiences, in both this and your other post, you really ought to do either of these two things: 1) move your jib fairlead WAY back to open up the top of the jib; 2) get a smaller jib, at least an 85% if not smaller.

We had a friend with a C25 who sailed on SF Bay and he bought a 65%!!! But he was the most comfortable sailor in our group!

You should also, as many suggested in your earlier post: reef, reef, reef the mainsail.

You are almost always horribly overpowered. THAT is why you're having these problems, and continuing to compare it to your earlier Ericson 27 ain't gonna help you one bit.

Don't blame it on flukey winds on your lake, blame yourself. (With apologies to Herman Cain).

Really, you should know from your long experiences with sailing that where you now are is not where you once were.

Good luck, but you really oughta print out and re-re-re-read the responses to both your posts.

How do I know all this? We had a C22 and learned to sail it in HEAVY conditions. How'd we do it? We reefed, reefed, reefed, moved the jib cars aft, stayed inside the boat, only used the hiking stick when things were relatively calm, and learned to sail the boat.

Good luck, but please: listen to the good advice you've been given. It really sounds to me like you want to sail your boat with the full main up and the 110% jib out in winds higher than that sail plan was designed for. Not a good idea.

BTW, the C22 as specifically designed to round up, all on its own, even without kicking the tiller down. You, actually, should know this by now.
 
May 13, 2012
37
mac mac ca
With your short arms, perhaps the extender will help, but if you're rockin' and rollin' as you describe, I would find it much too dangerous to sit on the coaming and try to steer.

When we had our C22, we had 2 seasons: summer on the lake and winters on San Francisco Bay. Sometimes we'd get up to the lake well after Memorial Day, so ended up sometimes in the BIG winds here on the Bay.

I would use the extender when things were calm and comfortable. Once the winds picked up, regardless of where the boat was (lake or Bay, and the lake could blow hard, too), I'd want to be inside the boat not on the edges.

Given your descriptions of your experiences, in both this and your other post, you really ought to do either of these two things: 1) move your jib fairlead WAY back to open up the top of the jib; 2) get a smaller jib, at least an 85% if not smaller.

We had a friend with a C25 who sailed on SF Bay and he bought a 65%!!! But he was the most comfortable sailor in our group!

You should also, as many suggested in your earlier post: reef, reef, reef the mainsail.

You are almost always horribly overpowered. THAT is why you're having these problems, and continuing to compare it to your earlier Ericson 27 ain't gonna help you one bit.

Don't blame it on flukey winds on your lake, blame yourself. (With apologies to Herman Cain).

Really, you should know from your long experiences with sailing that where you now are is not where you once were.

Good luck, but you really oughta print out and re-re-re-read the responses to both your posts.

How do I know all this? We had a C22 and learned to sail it in HEAVY conditions. How'd we do it? We reefed, reefed, reefed, moved the jib cars aft, stayed inside the boat, only used the hiking stick when things were relatively calm, and learned to sail the boat.

Good luck, but please: listen to the good advice you've been given. It really sounds to me like you want to sail your boat with the full main up and the 110% jib out in winds higher than that sail plan was designed for. Not a good idea.

BTW, the C22 as specifically designed to round up, all on its own, even without kicking the tiller down. You, actually, should know this by now.
Much thanks for all of your good advice. I will keep it all in mind. At this point though, I really do believe that my main mistakes were leaving the topping lift tight and attached and not working the mainsheet at all. I will soon find out as soon as the winds straiten out though. I will keep you posted on how it works out. I will keep the reef in mind but I am thinking that in 15 knot winds with a 110 jib, no more topping lift and mainsheet adjustment I should be fine. We'll see.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.