windlass installation need your suggestions

Nov 21, 2023
1
Hunter Legend 43 Point Roberts
Hello everyone,

The VW800 windlass on my 1991 Legend 43 is getting quite old, and I’m planning a proper upgrade. I’m currently weighing my windlass options and could use some advice. I already have a new Lofrans Tigres horizontal windlass, but due to the unique shape and design of the chain locker (bow roller on the port side, vertical windlass installed horizontally, and chain sliding rather than dropping freely), I’m considering three potential paths forward:

1) Upgrade to a VW1000 or a similar vertical-horizontal windlass.
This seems like the easiest solution since I’ve seen others take this route. However, the primary issue remains—the chain won’t freely drop into the locker and would need to be manually guided to slide down into the chain well, which could lead to operational trouble. Additionally, I’m not aware of any other brands of vertical windlasses that can be mounted horizontally, so the VW1000 seems to be the only viable option.

2) Use the Lofrans Tigres windlass I already have.
This would require significant modifications, including installing a new starboard-side bow roller and relocating the windlass further forward on the bow. Challenges include the substantial weight of the Lofrans windlass combined with the chain and its large size, which might be difficult to accommodate. Additionally, the mounting plate for the windlass could obstruct access to the furler’s location.

3) Sell the Lofrans windlass and buy a vertical windlass to install vertically.
This would involve remodeling and installing the new windlass on the port side, allowing me to reuse the existing bow roller. However, I’m uncertain about the potential financial loss when selling the brand-new Lofrans windlass and the cost of a new vertical one.

If you were in my position, which option would you choose? Any insights or advice would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!
 

Attachments

Dec 25, 2000
5,873
Hunter Passage 42 Shelter Bay, WA
The VW800 windlass on my 1991 Legend 43 is getting quite old,
Our 1991 P42 came with a Maxwell windlass that has performed quite well over the years. Our well looks just like yours. If it were my boat I would stay with a horizontal brand. I do not mind hand feeding the rode into the well as it comes in. That way I can inspect it on the way and/or deal with any issues, such as a stuck anchor.

Does your current windlass not work? I would keep it until it doesn't.