Thanks Chief for your reply. My experience has been with thru hull transducers, but a couple years ago we had a transducer failure. I thought and Googled and found the PUCK. So I installed with mineral oil as suggested by manufacturer, easy install and it worked great. End of season (Chesapeake) I removed the Puck and cleaned out the mineral oil, we hauled and before launch in spring installed another thru hull transducer, but I keep the Puck as a back up. I have used butyl for many years, had access to Navy yard materials, great stuff. I never thought of using it for the Puck. Don't see why it wouldn't work.Waterman: Wish I could help but do not know, nor have I tested Butyl tape. Chief