I tried Bed It butyl but because the 9000 screws (! ok it is a bunch, probably not that many) that go through, along with the clearance between the cover and the cabin top, made that a no-go. I think that something like 4200 applied liberally (the clearance under my cover is 1/4" in some places) and allowed to firm up a little before laying the cover back on and installing the screws might do the trick .. I think that is how it was installed at the factory. If the screws are tightened too much, it can crack or deform the cover in those places where there is a lot of clearance. The sealant doesn't have to seal tightly to the underside of the cover, but it does have to seal perfectly to the cabin top and the screws Best of luck and get us some pictures!