Uh- some of us have wooden masts. So yeah, they are a big help. And here on the Texas coast, with the massive amounts of commercial traffic, mine is up always.I think that's the question--is it? The vessels can be detected by radar w/o a radar reflector up-- so, do these things really "enhance" the target return? Sure, if you put 'em in a box and hit them with radar they'll bounce it back OK. BUT--do they significantly increase the return strength from a sailboat having a big aluminum mast and big spreaders already??