Interesting.
What is the cost of marine plywood + Teak & Holly Veneer plus finish coats
What is the cost of of Teak and Holly sole material (produced as cabin sole, veneer put on at the factory) plus finish coats?
What is the cost of marine plywood + Lonseal?
What is the cost of marine plywood + Plasteak?
All the same questions for using something other than marine plywood
What is your time worth and how much time will each method take? Set a reasonable number.
Make a spread sheet of all the factors and include final finished appearance as a "intangible factor (what is the final look your willing to pay for)
I only needed to replace two pieces and could get them done with one 4X8 Teak & Holly Sole (about $400). It was a challenge carefully sanding down the finish on the other pieces and matching the stain but it came out really nice. I used the original finish that Hunter put on which is Daly's Seafin.
Here is a picture of my refinished cabin sole. The "blue" is reflection from the ports onto the sole. The replaced piece is the big one directly below and to the right of the ladder.
View attachment 230373