Pearson 36-2 possible Rudder issue

Nov 2, 2016
56
Hunter 27 2 Rock hall MD
I came out to my boat after being away for a week and found the bilge running pretty frequently and water coming in the hole just above and to the right of the prop shaft drippless. I was able to stop the flow by moving everything out of my aft cabin, lazarette and emptying out the aft water tank. I did see some rusty water on the rudder shaft when inspected from the dock. Is this a seal failure or something else?
 
Jan 1, 2006
8,178
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
If emptying the aft water tank stopped the flow I would look for a leak in the tank, it's fitting and hoses.
 

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
24,926
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
clues provided:
  1. water coming in the hole just above and to the right of the prop shaft drippless.
  2. I was able to stop the flow by moving everything out of my aft cabin, lazarette and emptying out the aft water tank.
  3. I did see some rusty water on the rudder shaft when inspected from the dock
Lacking pictures and further information, we have 3 clues present.
I set aside #3. It is outside the boat. It may be involved in something else but not pertinent to the issue of water in the bilge.

Water in the bilge can come from two potential sources.
A- water from outside the boat getting in
B- water already in the boat finding its way to the bilge.

We have no information about the hole in clue #1. Where it comes from or how it is connected to other parts of the boat. Will ignore it for now.

Water was stopped by the action of clue #2. This action either resulted in raising the boat’s water line above the level of the outside water (no more outside water leaking in) or the emptying of the tank removed stored interior water from reaching the bilge.

My guess agrees with @shemandr. The potential of a failure at the water tank. That would be a reasoned place to investigate.
 
Nov 14, 2026
6
Catalina 27 Waukeegan, IL
Pictures will help. No one knows what hole you're referring to.
Are you sure your packing nut on the shaft doesn't need adjustment?
It should only drip when the boat is in gear.
 
Nov 2, 2016
56
Hunter 27 2 Rock hall MD
Any photos of the hole?
I’ll try to get a photo of the area shortly. I became busy trying to get to a haul out. For what it’s worth, it was salt water, not fresh. If anyone in here has a 36-2, it’s coming from the weep hole just right of the prop shaft when you pull up the floor board. It appears to come from the box or fiberglass housing that surrounds the rudder post in the lazarette. I suspect it was a lower rudder seal. The yard has it now.
 
Nov 2, 2016
56
Hunter 27 2 Rock hall MD
clues provided:

Lacking pictures and further information, we have 3 clues present.
I set aside #3. It is outside the boat. It may be involved in something else but not pertinent to the issue of water in the bilge.

Water in the bilge can come from two potential sources.
A- water from outside the boat getting in
B- water already in the boat finding its way to the bilge.

We have no information about the hole in clue #1. Where it comes from or how it is connected to other parts of the boat. Will ignore it for now.

Water was stopped by the action of clue #2. This action either resulted in raising the boat’s water line above the level of the outside water (no more outside water leaking in) or the emptying of the tank removed stored interior water from reaching the bilge.

My guess agrees with @shemandr. The potential of a failure at the water tank. That would be a reasoned place to investigate.
Thank you for replying. It was definitely salt water. I’ll try to get a photo of the area it came from shortly. Looks like a weep hole that comes from the fiberglass box surrounding the rudder shaft in the lazarette.
 
  • Like
Likes: jssailem
Jan 4, 2006
7,863
Hunter 310 West Vancouver, B.C.
For what it’s worth, it was salt water, not fresh.
Aw crap ! That makes it a little more difficult to diagnose rather than a simple leak associated with the water tank.

Do you have any manufacturer's manuals of your boat ? Have you been able to find the manual on this site ?

We'll wait for the pictures to get a better idea. The more pictures from every angle, the better.
 
Nov 2, 2016
56
Hunter 27 2 Rock hall MD
Aw crap ! That makes it a little more difficult to diagnose rather than a simple leak associated with the water tank.

Do you have any manufacturer's manuals of your boat ? Have you been able to find the manual on this site ?

We'll wait for the pictures to get a better idea. The more pictures from every angle, the better.
I don’t have any original manuals except the Yanmar manual. I’ll do search and see what I can find
 
Jan 1, 2006
8,178
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
Since I was wrong about the water tank I don't know if I should take another swing. But John suggested if the leak stopped with an empty water tank it might be the weight of the water that activates the leak. That would suggest the leak would be close to the actual water line. Therefore I would look into your exhaust system. Or cockpit drains which in several boats I've owned were at or under the waterline.
I guess my problem with the rudder tube theory is that normally the rudder tube is well above the water line. And I don't think of the rudder bearings as being seals to keep water out. But I don't know your boat.
I'm coming to understand that the hole you're talking about is likely a limber hole meant to allow water that gets into a hull space to drain to a low spot in the bilge to be pumped out.
 
Nov 2, 2016
56
Hunter 27 2 Rock hall MD
Since I was wrong about the water tank I don't know if I should take another swing. But John suggested if the leak stopped with an empty water tank it might be the weight of the water that activates the leak. That would suggest the leak would be close to the actual water line. Therefore I would look into your exhaust system. Or cockpit drains which in several boats I've owned were at or under the waterline.
I guess my problem with the rudder tube theory is that normally the rudder tube is well above the water line. And I don't think of the rudder bearings as being seals to keep water out. But I don't know your boat.
I'm coming to understand that the hole you're talking about is likely a limber hole meant to allow water that gets into a hull space to drain to a low spot in the bilge to be pumped out.
I agree, I think the hole is part of the aft bilge section. My exhaust is well above the water line and I was able to inspect it. The inside of the lazarette gave me access to the through hulls of the bilge and sink. But this water was coming from this fiberglass box that the top of the rudder post sticks out of. So I’m completely mystified by it.