Hi. I grew up sailing on Lake Erie -- well, Maumee Bay, really. The furthest east we ever got was West Sister Island. I would like to get a boat and back into sailing, but have very little idea how to evaluate a used boat, and especially a fiberglass hull. I'm looking at a 1989 Hunter 23 in Chicago. Any suggestions as to what in particular to take a close look at?
Sure! With one HUGE caveat. My knowledge of this boat is barely a mere drop in the ocean compared to the knowledge available on this forum. So with that in mind...
I looked at 2 1986 Hunter 23's being offered for sale at Strictly Sail in Cincinnati. Read many, many posts on here about this particular boat dating back to 1999 before buying it, so I didn't go in totally blind. Plus, being a licensed home inspector I have a bit of a talent for looking at things with a discerning eye.
Anyway, I sure someone with an infinite amount of wisdom concerning this boat will chime in soon (Dave? Peter? you guys have your ears on?!) But I will share my experience.
As I mentioned, I looked at both 23' Hunters at the lot. Both had very similar deficiencies in that they had taken on rainwater and had been left neglected. That rainwater built up and caused some rotting of the bulkheads. My next project, and likely the major project with this boat so far, is to cut out the rot in the rear bulkhead (just under companionway) and replace it.
I did notice that this problem existed on both boats I looked at, and definitely was a factor in the offer I made for the boat.
Both boats also had some rot in the front bulkhead at the v berth (I posted on this earlier in this thread.)
Although I don't believe I'll need to replace the front bulkhead, as the rot was minimal, it will need tabbed back in now that the area is dry.
I'd definitely suggest bringing a flashlight with you and looking in any nook and cranny on the boat for water damage. And the bonus is you can look inside the hull to see if there were any repairs from a past crash or some such.
The exterior hull on mine had been neglected so long and was chalky to touch...
Fortunately a friend has taken that project and is running with it. He's been at it 2 Saturdays now, wet sanding and whatnot... He's done great! The boat is starting to take a shine and all it's cost me is some beers!
There are some cracks in the gel coat on the topsides that will need addressed, but I think I'll do that while docked..
Open the port side lazarette locker and give that area a good look. Rudder pintles, cockpit drain, battery box, etc. Again, when I chose this boat, I knew it needed some work. And it was a big factor in the offer I made. I did look over the mast pretty closely - mainly making sure it wasn't cracked or something that would have been a no go... Just a couple t bolts bent. Sails were original, and although I didn't get to go over them fully at the dealership, they appeared, and still appear, serviceable. The running rigging will be replaced very soon. The dealership was asking $4k for the boat. I offered $2500 and, not without a minor amount of haggling, they relented.
So far, the cost to get this thing up to par has been pretty minimal - (except the outboard - but I could not find a used one anywhere). And a WHOLE bunch of elbow grease, but it really is a labor of love for me.
If you are reasonably handy, and the boat needs some work, go for it! Just make sure your offer reflects that. And don't overlook the resources on this forum... There at literally thousands of posts about Hunter 23's here!