Is fuel "polishing" worth the trouble??

Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gary Gulliksen

Poishing Fuel Is Worthwhile

Heavens YES, It is worthwhile to polish diesel fuel!
Two years ago we were moving the Ladybug, a 35.5 Ft. 1988 Hunter Legend from Stingray Point out Broad Creek Channel - (It is not really broad; and it is badly shoaled to very shallow water.)- to go to Regent Point on Locklies Creek. The tide was going out in addition to the Rappahannock River flow,and a 10-12 knot wind on our beam, just crabbing along into the wind and river flow with the Yanmar engine at about 2,500 RPM, as usual.
We were about half way out thru the channel when the engine sputtered to about 1,200 RPM. We could barely hold position into the wind.
Craig Akers was our guest on board. He ran for the anchor locker; but there was no sea room to set the hook before we'd be aground. He quickly suggested we deploy our 150% Genoa. The wind carried the Genny out on the roller furl in about three seconds; and we learned, with blessed relief, how well that Hunter Legend could claw off a lee shore.
We were able to sail up river to Regent Point Marine.
Later we learned that the filter was cloged from a bad load of fuel and I don't think the tank had ever been cleaned out since she was new.
I had the tank pumped and cleaned out by the boat yard at our marina.
Then I built a polishing system. Racor R20S filter/water seperator and a "Quick Drain" Engine Oil Change pump mounted in a nice box I built with intake and outflow diesel fuel hoses. I also use a 12 volt tire inflator from the auto parts store attached to a copper tube to "aggitate" the annual sludge at the tank bottom and thus let the filter do the work.
The pump has to be set close to level with your onboard diesel tank - It doesn't have much "head presure" ability - but works well to pump out fuel to jerry cans (I have three) and then I repour the filtered fuel back to the deck inlet- again, thru a filter. I don't think I don't think fuel can be polished/filtered too much.
 
Jun 16, 2009
1
2 Legend 40.5 Sandusky
Fuel Polishing

I added a Fuel Polishing system 2 years ago. I really don't know how clean my tank is now but the boat does run better. If you are considering adding a system to your boat I would recommend making sure the value you add to the fuel line which is needed to return the fuel to the tank is higher than the fuel tank. My value which is lower than the tank failed and I had a drip of fuel for about four weeks going into my bilge. It happened after I the boat came out for the winter. I also found the return line needs a shut off value as well. It took all winter to get the boat clean and the smell out.

I really don't know if I would do it again, the portable unit at the dealer is a lot less expensive. But if the motor shuts off it will be in rough water because the junk on the bottom of the tank is mixed in the fuel and plug everything up. Consider where you sail if that happens you can be safe until help arrives.
 

Bob J.

.
Apr 14, 2009
774
Sabre 28 NH
A diesel motor in a boat is no different than a diesel in any other piece of equipment.

If you add a diesel fuel conditioner as part of an ongoing maintence program, (every fill up) don't let your tank get less than 1/2 empty & buy fuel from a high volume pump, there should be no need to polish the fuel. Although it has a nice enviromental ring to it, I wouldn't buy biodiesel. The fuel seperates over time & becomes like peanut butter in the bottom of the tank, (even with conditioner) & usually leads to an injector pump replacement on smaller motors.

Just my .02 but it's based upon running small diesel motors in a variety of equipment for the past 30 years.

Bob
 
Jul 20, 2005
2,422
Whitby 55 Kemah, Tx
A diesel motor in a boat is no different than a diesel in any other piece of equipment.
Bob
Sorry Bob but I totally disagree. Most other pieces of equipment don't have fuel sitting in them for years like most boats do. Most other pieces of equipment don't run in as rough conditions as boats do. Conditions such as saltly air/water, bouncy conditions when the weather gets rough.

Also, marine fuel docks don't get the use like gas stations do.
 

Ross

.
Jun 15, 2004
14,693
Islander/Wayfairer 30 sail number 25 Perryville,Md.
Sorry Bob but I totally disagree. Most other pieces of equipment don't have fuel sitting in them for years like most boats do. Most other pieces of equipment don't run in as rough conditions as boats do. Conditions such as saltly air/water, bouncy conditions when the weather gets rough.

Also, marine fuel docks don't get the use like gas stations do.
Franklin, You need to spend more time on construction sites and on farms. The dust and rough road conditions in construction and agriculture rival any marine conditions I have encountered.
 
Aug 2, 2005
374
pearson ariel grand rapids
Agree with Ross, Been in construction too long (and worked on a farm) to view a boat engine as having it harder.
The only time a boat installation will be harder on an engine is in the case of a raw water cooled one where the engine doesn't really ever reach -proper- operating temps, that will tear an engine up in short order.
Ever see how rough a bobcat's 'normal' day is? With most construction companies, the equipment is treated hard, (The operator's don't own it, and they get a break WITH pay if it breaks down) and then it's put away wet (3:30, park it and run) and is only maintained when it's almost too late.

You do run into companies that maintain their equipment with high standards, but not as many as you'd expect.

Ken.
 

Bob J.

.
Apr 14, 2009
774
Sabre 28 NH
Hey Franklin,

I think that fuel contamanation? is influenced by a variety of factors. I know that everytime we would haul down south to go jeeping we were good for at least 1 fuel filter in the pick-up if we bought fuel at a low volume station in lieu of a truck stop. That never happened up north so warmer climates & low fuel turn over does promote critters in diesel.

With that said, I don't think it's fuel sitting around in a sailboat tank that's the issue as much as purchasing fuel from questionable sources. It would be best to purchase diesel at a pump that services a charter fleet/sport fishing boats if possible.
I'd also top off the fuel tank more often, even though it's a PIA. I have to assume that a sailboater purchasing fuel drives them crazy in much the same way as someone who heats their home with wood.

I think if boaters would adhere to a strick maintence schedule, (filters, water seperator, fuel additives) polishing wouldn't be necessary. From what I've read on this thread, polishing appears to be nothing more than continous circulation thru another filter/water seperator. I could be wrong.

Cheers!
Bob
 
B

basicallyskip@comcast.net

Fuel Polishing gadgets

Then there is this guy at the Seattle boat show selling a "magnetic" device to "improve the energy bonds" of the fuel molecules. Sell me a bridge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.