Cutting a sail free in a surprise squall

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mar 23, 2009
139
Rafiki 35 North East, MD
We have a sloop-rigged Grampian 26 keelboat that we've been restoring and sailing for the past 3 years.

Last night, we were sailing south from the North East River down the upper Chesapeake Bay in very light winds with the mainsail and a hank-on 140 genoa. Just before midnight, the wind died out altogether. Heavy fog set in. Because we were approaching the shipping channel for the C&D Canal and wanted to keep steerage, we dropped the sails and started the outboard motor. The headsail went into a bag snapped around the forestay and the mainsail was rolled on top of the boom and tied down with 4 lengths of 3/8" line held with reefing knots.

We checked weather predictions again and saw that the wind wasn't expected to pick up until the next day. Although we had planned an overnight sail, given the heavy fog and lack of wind, we decided to go up the Sassafras River to spend the night near Lloyd's Creek. Shortly after entering the mouth of the Sassafras, we saw what looked like "heat" lightning off in the distance. Within minutes, the lightning was flashing all around us and above us in the upper atmosphere without touching down. The barometer held steady and the water was still, as we motored at approximately 2 knots.

Then the boat was hit by what I can only describe as a wall of wind from the stern that heeled us over and spun us to starboard. Even with no sail up we were heeled to 20 degrees so suddenly that I crashed knee-first into the other side of the cockpit. My gut reaction was to steer into the wind. Water that had been flat moments before sent cresting waves crashing over the bow. My wife went below to close the portlights and get our PFDs. Sudden driving rain limited visibility to about 3 feet past the bow, though I could see an illuminated channel marker some distance ahead as we were faced west into the wind but being driven east up the river while I tried to steer us out of the channel, which ran quite close to the lee shore. Within 5 minutes of the first gust hitting us, another gust hit us, spinning us back to port. Wind caught in the folds of the main sail, blowing open one and then two sail ties, creating a parachute of sail in the middle of the boom.

We were instantly heeled so far to port that I was standing on the side of the cockpit bench while fastening my PFD. My wife took the helm and I pulled myself forward to fasten the sail, using the first handy line (the tail of the main halyard) to lash it to the boom. Within moments of my return to relieve my screaming wife in the cockpit, part of the sail blew open again in another gust, this time heeling us so far that the port side toerail was below the water while waves crashed over the cabin house roof. The outboard prop was out of the water and we shut the motor off.

I went to the mast again, but could not pull the sail to the boom given the wind conditions. At one point, I was hanging on to the boom to keep from going over. We had lost sight of all channel markers and knew nothing of our location except that the depth had gone from 15 ft to 7 ft and I feared we'd soon run aground. In desperation, I slashed the sail along the boom and near the mast to cut it free.

Once the sail was off, the boat partially righted, though were still unable to steer. We went aground on shoals and were knocked off into deeper water. Now that I thought I'd be able to stay on the forward deck, I went to the bow and dropped our main anchor. Our wooden dinghy, tied to the stern, had been swamped and flipped. Though it still floated due to the flotation I'd built into it, it was catching the moving water like a scoop and keeping the bigger boat from turning into the wind. Unable to pull it from the water, I set it free.

We dropped a second anchor off of the bow and then rode out the remainder of the storm down below while listening to another nearby boat calling the Coast Guard for help on the VHF radio. Though it felt like a lifetime, only 30 minutes had passed since the first gust hit.

When the sun came up, we realized we were no more than 100 feet from a shore and had blown more than 2 miles up river during the storm before setting our anchors. We learned this morning that boats at a nearby yacht club dragged their permanent moorings hundreds of yards in the storm and that gusts were measured at up to 80 mph. We did not recover our dinghy.

I certainly know now to lash the sail more tightly to the boom before a storm hits, even when dropping it in light air conditions. Aside from sharing that lesson, I'd like to hear advice from other sailors about what we should or could have done differently during the storm to avoid having to cut the mainsail off. Has this ever happened to anybody else?

The attached photos were taken while we were assessing the damage and then sailing home with a jib this morning.
 

Attachments

RichH

.
Feb 14, 2005
4,773
Tayana 37 cutter; I20/M20 SCOWS Worton Creek, MD
You did real good .... you walked away with only minor damage. Sail the Ches. for any time and you'll meet such weather - again.

Worton Creek, a few miles south of you had constant repeating gusts over 70+ kts.

Best advice I can give is dont use flimsy tape-like sail tie 'gaskets'. I use honest to goodness 3/8 - 7/16 dia. ROPE with large knotted eyes in the end. I then tie in 'double wrapped' square knots (two wraps around the 'loops' instead of the usual 'one wrap'. Been there in prolonged F9 conditions ... and then is not the time you want a sail to become loose.

Several years ago a 'raft up' at the mouth of Still Pond Creek got hit with 20 minutes of 70 knots 'straight line' winds .... and most of the 'raft' of 15+ boats got blown well up onto the shore by the old CG station .... wasnt pretty and with lots of heavy boat damage.

Never put your trust in a NOAA forecasts on the Ches. If you have any suspicions, turn your AM radio to a 'quiet' station near 1000-1100 kHz ... and if you hear lots of 'crackling' on the AM, ..... RUN for the closest port or to the expected windward shore and anchor close-in if you cant make it to a port. This is especially important when in Summer and a VERY hot day brings 'sudden fog and heavy mist' at night or a 'coppery looking' fog/mist during late in the day ..... batten the hatches !!!!!! Get a VHF radio with a Wx ALARM that 'works'.

BTW - I left my boat at Worton Creek that evening as 'the omens' for a 'stink' night were already evident at dusk ... very high dewpoint, developing mist/fog over WARM water ... and as soon as the evenings lower temperature 'meets' the dewpoint temperature you usually get a severely intensifying BLAMMO.

Lucky for you you only lost a sail. Glad you could 'walk away'.

regards
RichH
 

zeehag

.
Mar 26, 2009
3,198
1976 formosa 41 yankee clipper santa barbara. ca.(not there)
heard there was a derecha gone thru there and winds were upward from 60 kts.. glad yer ok--is a small boat for that kinda mayhem winds...
 

gpd955

.
Feb 22, 2006
1,164
Catalina 310 Cape May, NJ
Matt

Glad to see you guys came out of it ok! We were in a slip and i was taking water on deck and looking at my neighbors bottom through my portlight. Downright nasty last night.
 

Ross

.
Jun 15, 2004
14,693
Islander/Wayfairer 30 sail number 25 Perryville,Md.
The damage on land exceeds the damage from Hurricane Isobel. at least 13 killed by trees a half million customers without power some for the rest of the week.
My sail ties are all about six feet long with a leather patch in the middle. I center the patch on the sail and bring the ends around to the patch and tie a slipped reef knot.
 

xcyz

.
Jan 22, 2008
174
Hunter 376
Lightning Strike in VA near Clifton

Lightning struck my neighbors tree last night just before 12am. WOW what a show that was...:eek:

There was a run on fuel and ice and heard of many fights at the few service stations that were pumping today. Still over 1.2m homes are w/o power.
 

Attachments

Jan 14, 2011
243
tanzer tanzer 28 bathurst nb
i would have loosen the main sheet and let it trash, but in the heat of the moment you did what you could think of to save your boat, and you both got off unharmed and in good health with minimal damage. You did good.
 

Ross

.
Jun 15, 2004
14,693
Islander/Wayfairer 30 sail number 25 Perryville,Md.
i would have loosen the main sheet and let it trash, but in the heat of the moment you did what you could think of to save your boat, and you both got off unharmed and in good health with minimal damage. You did good.
Maybe you would have thought to do that and maybe you wouldn't have. We weren't there.
The storm arrived last night at sixty miles per hour. When he left NorthEast harbor that storm was in Ohio. I went to bed at ten O'clock and it was completely calm, by midnight we had lightning and rain and wind.
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,076
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
So glad you are safe.

Closing portlights. I know it gets hot where you sail, but why do you sail with hatches and ports open?

Just a simple question.

Mobo wakes and your experience would seem to suggest keeping them closed all the time.

We do, but it's much cooler here.

Great story. Thanks.
 
Jan 10, 2009
590
PDQ 32 Deale, MD
So much for some posters I've heard claim they can sail through any squall and the gusts over 45 knots on the Chesapeake are unheard of. Rare, but not rare enough.

I've been hit like that twice: once anchored in a good spot, but boats in more open areas got knocked into things, as pilings let go; the other, with a beach cat, and that didn't go so well. The boat cartwheeled right across the beach, with no canvas up.

Since I can never tell what a squall is packing, I treat them all with great respect.
 
Jun 6, 2006
6,990
currently boatless wishing Harrington Harbor North, MD
Kinda makes a case for keeping that weather radio on all the time or at least checking it on a regular schedule. I think the handiest thing my VHF has is the weather watch function. It goes to the all hazards weather channels if it detects the warning tones of a weather alert.

Glad you came through with not loss of life or limb.
 
Aug 20, 2010
1,399
Oday 27 Oak Orchard
Let's see, in a channel and extreme conditions arising unexpectedly with nowhere to go and minimal damage to the boat. Outstanding seamanship! You make a good case for the hanked on jib. One of the reasons I pitched the rolly furly as soon as my boat came out for restoration. I couldn't trust a 5/16ths line to keep a 150 coiled during a blow. All my new sails are hanked on.
 

Ross

.
Jun 15, 2004
14,693
Islander/Wayfairer 30 sail number 25 Perryville,Md.
I have learned that you just can't have too much rope on board for lashing things.
 

Ross

.
Jun 15, 2004
14,693
Islander/Wayfairer 30 sail number 25 Perryville,Md.
Get a weather radio.
It wouldn't have helped! They saw lightning in the distance( and at that point you can see ten miles to the west. ) But that storm was moving with the speed and force of an 18 wheeler on the interstate.
 
May 7, 2012
1,567
Hunter e33 Maple Bay, BC
In no way is this intended to be judgemental. Under the conditions you have described, you and your crew did more than great.

I suggest making the boat as watertight as possibly by closing all openings including port holes and hatches (companionway too) preferrably at all times but at least when you realized the weather was going down the dumper. Also once things got ugly I suggest using tethers for both you and your crew.

Sent from the comfort of home.
 

luken7

.
Aug 21, 2010
96
Beneteau Oceanis 361 Oriental
I wild just add, keep your lifevests in the cockpit with you instead of down below. Other than that, fantastic work and we're all glad it worked out ok and you guys are safe.
 
Oct 2, 2006
1,517
Jboat J24 commack
You did well

It was very violent week of storms on Long Island with crazy stuff Monday several TIMES

And ever wilder stuff Thursday night and again 5 AM Friday
 
Status
Not open for further replies.