C27 vs. Ericson 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Brian

Sold my 22, will be buying a bigger boat very soon. I loved by C22 but have outgrown it. I am looking at a 1980 C27, 1974 C27 (older but better equipped), a 1974 Ericson 27, or a 1981 SanJuan 26. All are about the same asking price. Any thougts/pros/cons? I don't know much about Ericsons - any input? I have read some posts mentioning problems with older C27's. Will mostly be week or week-end cruising Puget Sound and possibly San Juan Islands. Responses much appreciated.
 
B

Bob Camarena

If you love your 22...

If you love your Catalina 22, you'll adore the C-27. The C-22, 25, 27, 30, and 36 all have a strong family resemblence. I'd lean toward the newer C-27 unless it's in worse condition than the '74. On the other hand, if the '74 has been lovingly maintained it might be a good deal. I('d aldo opt for the "traditional" interior over the dinette model. You didn't mention whether or not they were inboards or outboards. There are a number of postings on the tradeoffs in the archives, but personally, I'd opt for the outboard, particularly over an older Atomic 4. It sails faster and is cheaper to replace if necessary.
 
R

Rob

Boats

There is an Ericson 27 in the marina next to me - boy does it have SWEET lines. Nice triangular transom. No joke. Of course, that's all I know about it - but its one good looking boat. I would certainly investigate it. Owning a 1979 C-27 - I can tell you that support and parts are easy to obtain. This website alone is a serious benefit (kudos to those who maintain it) that will help you if you choose the C-27. Older 27's will should get the chainplates and spreader brackets replaced, for sure. Rigging is also a sore spot, and needs close inspection. Individual boats will have their own achilles heels, but a good survey will tell you what to look out for. I would lean toward the 80 since it is newer, but I have seen 75's that are in better shape than 80's models. It all depends on the individual boat, and, more importantly, its owner. Remeber, upgrades like instruments are easy - replacing something like a deck is not. As for engines, don't worry about inboards or outboards. The most important thing to look at is the overall condition of the engine - regardless of type. Has it been taken care of? Is there a maintenance log? Does it fire quickly and surely, every time? I have an Atomic 4 inboard, and it is a wonderful engine - but they can be less than ideal if not properly taken care of. The same can be said of a deisel or outboard, for that matter (though outboards are cheaper to swap). Deisel replacements are the most costly, with an A-4 rebuild costing about half to a quarter of that, and a new 9.9 hp motor will run around 2 grand or so. Hope that helps, and let us know what you find, and what you decide. Best Regards, Rob
 
R

Roger

Faced the Same Choice

After a lot of research, I boiled my choice down to the same two boats last year. The big advantage for Catalinas is the great support from all the owners, as mentioned above. An advantage to the Ericson is the wider decks for ease of getting forward. I got a 1982 C27, and, although getting forward, especially around a dodger is a little tricky, it is just a great boat to sail. In my view, a very nice balance between good sailing performance and comfort. Lots of head room, plus air and light from the wide companionway hatch below, etc. I have the Universal 5411, and it has proven very dependable. When you get aboard the boat-that-will-be yours, I think you will know it! Good luck.
 
R

Roger

Faced teh Same Choice

After a lot of research, I boiled my choice down to the same two boats last year. The big advantage for Catalinas is the great support from all the owners, as mentioned above. An advantage to the Ericson is the wider decks for ease of getting forward. I got a 1982 C27, and, although getting forward, especially around a dodger is a little tricky, it is just a great boat to sail. In my view, a very nice balance between good sailing performance and comfort. Lots of head room, plus air and light from the wide companionway hatch below, etc. I have the Universal 5411, and it has proven very dependable. When you get aboard the boat-that-will-be yours, I think you will know it! Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.