MY objection to the West Wight Potter 19 is the daggerboard instead of centerboard. I like to run up on the beach or in shallows - the daggerboard is not nearly as handy.
Other reasons I chose a Mariner over a WWP 19:
- larger cockpit (does mean less cabin space)
- faster - much more sail area on longer waterline
- not slab sided - less windage when trying to anchor or dock. Easier to board from the water.
- much less costly for the same condition. WWP has a cult following which keeps used prices considerably higher, IMO.
OTOH, the WWP19 has a much nicer cabin. My original intention for the boat was day sailing for 2-4, so the bigger cockpit and beachability of the Mariner were big pluses. Turns out 5 years later mostly daysailing, some overnighting, mostly single handed. Mariner cabin is just OK for 1-2 for a couple of nights.
All up weight of Mariner with trailer is right at 2,000 lbs, easily towed by my minivan or V6 SUV (Hyundai Palisade, Kia Sorento, Honda Oydessy). Have towed from Indiana to eastern NC, and NC to Connecticut.
Fred W
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Sweet P