AMICA
I have been an AMICA customer for over 3o years. In that time I had one auto accident and lost a boat. They did not give me a hard time about either issue. In fact, when we lost the boat in a hurricane, they found money in our homeowners policy (also with AMICA) for personal possesions on the boat. They are a great company and very competitive in rates. Remember that it is a mutual insurance company so the profit at the end of the year does not go to shareholders, it goes to the policy holders as a rebate of premiums paid.