Awlgrip: Great paint or great marketing

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tim R.

.
May 27, 2004
3,626
Caliber 40 Long Range Cruiser Portland, Maine
I have always wondered why people think Awlgrip is such great paint.

My boat is currently getting some touch ups to repair some gouges in the paint on the topsides. My paint job is 10 years old. The boat next to mine is getting all new paint because it is faded and worn looking. His paint is only 8 years old. He looked at my boat and thought it was freshly painted(before any work was done).

The difference is that my boat was painted with Imron and his was painted with Awlgrip. My boat did not always look this great. It was pretty good but after buffing it 3 years ago it looks like new. You cannot buff Awlgrip. Is it possible to maintain Awlgrip to prevent the aging and fading?

He is now repainting with Imron.

Here is what my paint looks like after 10 years:



 
Sep 25, 2008
7,337
Alden 50 Sarasota, Florida
Not sure if this is a "my dad is bigger than your dad" discussion but I've had surprisingly good experience with our Awlgrip hull wwith what most would probably consider to be virtually no maintenance except for touching up a couple of scratches which wasn't as difficult as reputed.
If I were to do it over, I'd probably opt for Awlcraft although that too has it's negatives.

You can judge for yourself from the second pic on this link:

http://www.sailblogs.com/member/illusion/

Hard for me to tell if there is any paint truly superior to their competition as each seems to have some downsides on the topsides :D
 

Tim R.

.
May 27, 2004
3,626
Caliber 40 Long Range Cruiser Portland, Maine
Looks great Don. Maybe it has to do with exposure. The awlgrip boat is kept at a mooring as is mine.
 
Oct 2, 2006
1,517
Jboat J24 commack
Having sprayed Perfection and PPG DCC (its there Imron) and payed money to do it no less ;)



The Perfection is a PITA to follow the rules with a fairly endless amount of ways you can wrong that require a do over :eek:

I would say the Perfection might be a BIT tougher BUT you have pretty much ZERO chance of doing a blended repair

And flow my bacon you spray a mast and cut in 30 seconds to late and you will have a small issue that would never happen with auto paint
 

Tim R.

.
May 27, 2004
3,626
Caliber 40 Long Range Cruiser Portland, Maine
I have rolled and tipped perfection and it came out great once I had it thinned properly. I do not think it is as tough as Imron though.
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,701
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
I think

I think Linear polyurethanes like Awlgrip, Alexseal & Sterling all have their place. They are tough paints but they lack in the repairability department. The tough outer shell is also very, very thin, so while it may be tough it is easy to chafe through with a fender or winter cover.. LPU's can often out last Imron or Awlcraft 2000, in pure shine, before they would need to be buffed. Unfortunately when they do need it they can't be buffed and need to be re-painted.

I have seen regular Awlgrip look amazing at 12+ years, and I know some with Awlgrip nearing 20 years, but that is on a megayacht that is pampered by a crew of three 24/7. Hatteras used Imron for years and perhaps still do. They used it for its repairability. My buddy Gerry's Imron painted 100 footer still looks amazing and he bought it new in 1995. To replace an engine on boat like this they cut the hull sides open and extract it through the top sides. Imron allowed Gerry to not have to re-paint an entire side of his boat just the hole where the engine came out. The blend was not discernible. You can't do a blend like that with Awlgrip without it being noticeable. His boat spends 70% of it's time in the hot Florida Keys sun at the Ocean Reef Club and summers in the North East. The boat gets used and has only been buffed once in 15 years that I know of. If that had been AwlGrip it might not have looked quite as good at this age due to the lack of buffability. Not painting an entire side of a 100 footer also saved him a used 90's Catalina 30 price wise..;);)

My own boat is painted with Awlcraft 2000 but if I were to do it today I would have used Imron MS-600. While I really love my Awlcraft I have seen some recent MS-600 jobs out of Morris & New England Fiberglass that look simply amazing.

For a decks or non-skid areas I'd likely still opt for Awlgrip but for the top sides I would use a two part acrylic urethane like Awlcraft 2000 or Imron MS-600. I have owned Awlgriped boats before and it is the reason I now have an Awlcraft painted vessel.

Repairability and buffability are big bonuses with any paint..
 
Jul 1, 2004
567
Hunter 40 St. Petersburg
I don't understand

where this mantra of not being able to buff or repair Awlgrip comes from.

I've buffed out fender rash and other boo-boo's on mine. We're at ten years and I think it's doing fine.

Maybe it's good not to know any better.
 

Attachments

Feb 6, 1998
11,701
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
where this mantra of not being able to buff or repair Awlgrip comes from.

I've buffed out fender rash and other boo-boo's on mine. We're at ten years and I think it's doing fine.

Maybe it's good not to know any better.
The mantra is straight from the source, Awlgrip:

Awlgrip said:
Do not use abrasives, scratch pads, or compounds. Scratching the surface gives dirt a place to cling while wearing out the resin layer. Using abrasives of any kind will reduce the overall life of the finish and voids the Awlgrip Limited Warranty.


Awlgrip cures like a clear coat / base coat system with the clear very hard solids rising to the surface of the paint creating a hard, high shine shell. If you buff through this very, very thin layer you've ruined the finish.

Essentially the linear polyester resins can not be re-melted, well actually they can, but the melt/temp window is sooo narrow that you go from re-melt to destroy in just a few degree window. What actually happens when you compound or buff a painted surface is surface melt, because the window time of time between melt & disintegrate is so narrow on AwlGrip it is virtually impossible to buff or polish without destroying the thin hard protective shell if you are not a pro and even then lots of pro's ruin Awlgrip..

It is nearly impossible for a novice who has not had serious specialty training or years working with LPU's, to keep an LPU at the right temp to re-melt without destroying it in the process. To dumb it down it sort of goes like this when buffing Awlgrip.


To cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, to cool, melt (right temp for a split second), destroyed.......

Acrylic Urethane two part paints such as Imron MS600 or Awlcraft can be buffed because the re-melt window is much wider and they don't cure the same as an LPU. The pigment on an acrylic urethane is the full thickness not sitting under the clear solids..

This photo illustrates a destroyed Awlgrip finish. Note the shine on the majority of the hull even after many years. Now look at the center of the photo and you'll notice a large dull area. This is what happens when you chew through Awlgrips "protective shell". It is destroyed...



Do people buff AwlGrip? Yes but it should only be as a last resort because you will then be a slave to it and it will require AwlCare frequently to maintain a shine..

Here's what AwlGrip has to say (not my words theirs):

Awlgrip said:
Do not use abrasives, scratch pads, or compounds. Scratching the surface gives dirt a place to cling while wearing out the resin layer. Using abrasives of any kind will reduce the overall life of the finish and voids the Awlgrip Limited Warranty.
Anything in contact with the Awlgrip can eventually wear through the outer hard shell "resin layer". While it is very hard it is also very, very thin..

This is why products like Awlcraft 2000 which is repairable and buffable, are seeing growth in the paint market and Awlgrip, according to my local Akzo rep anyway, is beginning to sag in market share.
 
Jul 1, 2004
567
Hunter 40 St. Petersburg
Um, okay,

but they also say that you can't use any products other than their Awlcare wax stuff. I bought it, used it, and it sucks.

Listen, I know nobody knows a product better than the folks who made it, but IMHO some of these same folks resort to marketing tactics that are just plain wrong.

I'm not smart enough to explain why my experience flies in the face of the Awlgrip party line, but it does, and I'm simply sharing it here.

Yeah, I recognize that rash in your photo. I used to have some like it (okay, maybe not quite that bad.) It buffed out no problem. I do agree that you have to be careful not to burn the paint but I'd imagine that applies to most products.

Anyway, even if we don't always agree I still appreciate your posts here. I've learned a lot from you.

Fair winds.
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,701
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
but they also say that you can't use any products other than their Awlcare wax stuff. I bought it, used it, and it sucks.

Listen, I know nobody knows a product better than the folks who made it, but IMHO some of these same folks resort to marketing tactics that are just plain wrong.

I'm not smart enough to explain why my experience flies in the face of the Awlgrip party line, but it does, and I'm simply sharing it here.

Yeah, I recognize that rash in your photo. I used to have some like it (okay, maybe not quite that bad.) It buffed out no problem. I do agree that you have to be careful not to burn the paint but I'd imagine that applies to most products.

Anyway, even if we don't always agree I still appreciate your posts here. I've learned a lot from you.

Fair winds.
Rick,

If you buff it it will shine because you are likely now buffing the pigment under the hard shell if you've burned through the resin layer. When you then put wax on it it will continue to shine, this is why you can become a "slave" to it because you've now lost the protective resin layer. If you let all the wax get stripped off and you burned through the outer shell you'll then see the discolored areas again. It is quite possible you did not burn through the resin layer yet. It may even be possible you have Awlcraft? Many yards now spray Awlcraft 2000 but still refer to it as Awlgrip, though this is probably unlikely @ 10 years old..

I am not making up the way Awlgrip buffs or does not. I have spent considerable time talking with Dave the owner of New England Fiberglass about this, as his booth is next to the booth I work, at the Maine Boat Builders Show, he was Ted Hood's paint guru for years before he left to start New England Fiberglass.

I have also attempted to buff it. I owned an Alwgriped boat that got winter cover chafe and spent nearly a half hour on the phone with Awlgrip tech support. I also see the local rep at the yard and chat with him too.

My paint was far out of warranty and they could have cared less if I was going to use Awlcare because I had already told them I had a couple of bottles. I was still told exactly what I wrote above and that was, not to buff it. I was also told to use Awlcare and not Collinite despite the fact that they already knew I owned it and would not be spending even more money on Awlcare. The advice they gave was genuine from a customer service prospective. I even asked it they could recommend a "pro" who understood the "melt" point stuff better than I? The answer was still "you should not buff it".

I still buffed it.:doh: Though very, very gently. It did seem to minimize the chafe and then when I waxed it, it seemed to look even better, I did use Awlcare. By the next spring every chafe mark was back because I went to light and never really buffed anything due to how hard Awlgrip is.

Tech support was right and they did not have to be as they had already made their money off me. The only time they even hint at buffing it is when it is on it's last legs and then buff it til you finally wear through the pigment..

The magic of Awlgrip is its resin layer, which is thin and hard, but can be burned through. Perhaps you have not burned through it yet or the wax is just not letting you see that.

At 10 years you don't have much to lose, but buffing it earlier in its life can be an expensive mistake..

I actually find Awlcare to be decent stuff (actually costs about the same as Collinite;)), though not nearly as long lasting as Collinite, but I won't use Collinite on my Awlcraft.

This was our boat on the day she came out of the water, untouched, and after nearly six months with only Awlcare..
 
Oct 2, 2006
1,517
Jboat J24 commack
Maine

I used the Collinite by hand do you really feel it has any abrasives in it ?
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,701
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
Maine

I used the Collinite by hand do you really feel it has any abrasives in it ?
Not to worry Collinite does not have any abrasives either. The reason Awlgrip suggests not using a wax, carnuba based as opposed to a polymer based product, is because they can trap and attract dust and dirt and potentially yellow. I've never noticed any yellowing with Collinite. Also many so called "waxes" these days do contain abrasives. A wax or polymer sealer should not contain abrasives, but many do..

I don't feel using Collinite is any real big deal, but I did choose to use Awlcare on my new 10k finish while still under warranty. It works well, IMHO, so I am still using it, but does require a min of two coats and does not last as long as Collinite does in my experience.

It also has mild cleaning properties (stoddard solvent), that seem to really get any diesel soot and water spots off. I'm sure there are other non-abrasive polymer sealants that are comparable to Awlcare but at $13.00 I wasn't going to go chasing them down especially when the paint was still covered under a warranty.

I've been using Awlcare since day one and will likely continue to do so as my paint still look as good as brand new, at almost five years old. I hope to get to ten years or more before needing to polish it. if the five year mark is any indication I should be in very good shape..

We used Collinite on Tim R.'s Imron and it has been fine, looked great, and lasted, though Tim would be a better judge of how long it actually still beaded water.

I put on two coats of Awlcare each spring and it is still beading when we haul out.
 
Sep 25, 2008
7,337
Alden 50 Sarasota, Florida
For what it's worth, my experience is the difference between Awlcare and Collinite, in terms of longevity or appearance, is negligible.
I made the mistake one year of picking the wrong bottle out of the dock box thinking it was Awlcare (white top) and waxed the whole stb side before realizing it was a bottle of Collinite. Rectifying that mistake on the port topsides resulted in no apparent difference at the end of the season nor has it effected the long-term appearance.

The "which type lube oil is best" metaphor comes to mind every time I read one of these "which wax is best" debates.
 
Sep 25, 2008
2,288
C30 Event Horizon Port Aransas
I don't feel using Collinite is any real big deal, but I did choose to use Awlcare on my new 10k finish while still under warranty.
Was the 10k just for the topsides or does that include the deck? I am trying to get a perspective of the breakdown of the cost. Is there a considerable amount of labor like painting a car?
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,701
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
Was the 10k just for the topsides or does that include the deck? I am trying to get a perspective of the breakdown of the cost. Is there a considerable amount of labor like painting a car?
Topsides only. It's the prep work that kills you... Up here it's usually $200-300 per foot depending upon how bad the hull is and what you want for boot & cove stripes etc..

Our boat was actually broad sided at a fuel dock by a home built steam launch that lost power. No structural damage but lots of glass filling and fairing to do before the actual painting. Also to prevent "print through" with a darker color extra layers of high build was used and then it was feather boarded and faired. A wet sand and paint would be closer to $200 ft.. Add otehr stuff and it climbs. Perhaps with all the cheap labor in TX you can get a significantly better deal?
 
Sep 25, 2008
2,288
C30 Event Horizon Port Aransas
Perhaps with all the cheap labor in TX you can get a significantly better deal?
$8 an hour if you drive up in a pickup truck to Lowes in the morning. I'm sure I could find a fiberglass and paint expert in the bunch. Yo hablo espanol.
 
Dec 12, 2009
14
Cheoy Lee Wittholtz 53' Portsmouth, RI
We used Epifanes when we painted our boat. It was a lot cheaper than Awlgrip, and I think that the results were as good as any Awlgrip I've ever seen. Epifanes is a good product to use if you're doing it the roll and tip method. We tried spraying it the first two coats, but could never get the flow right. Finished it with roller and tipping method and are very pleased with the outcome after three seasons.
 
Oct 25, 2005
735
Catalina 30 Banderas Bay, Mexico
I think Linear polyurethanes like Awlgrip, Alexseal & Sterling all have their place. They are tough paints but they lack in the repairability department. The tough outer shell is also very, very thin, so while it may be tough it is easy to chafe through with a fender or winter cover.. LPU's can often out last Imron or Awlcraft 2000, in pure shine, before they would need to be buffed. Unfortunately when they do need it they can't be buffed and need to be re-painted.

I have seen regular Awlgrip look amazing at 12+ years, and I know some with Awlgrip nearing 20 years, but that is on a megayacht that is pampered by a crew of three 24/7. Hatteras used Imron for years and perhaps still do. They used it for its repairability. My buddy Gerry's Imron painted 100 footer still looks amazing and he bought it new in 1995. To replace an engine on boat like this they cut the hull sides open and extract it through the top sides. Imron allowed Gerry to not have to re-paint an entire side of his boat just the hole where the engine came out. The blend was not discernible. You can't do a blend like that with Awlgrip without it being noticeable. His boat spends 70% of it's time in the hot Florida Keys sun at the Ocean Reef Club and summers in the North East. The boat gets used and has only been buffed once in 15 years that I know of. If that had been AwlGrip it might not have looked quite as good at this age due to the lack of buffability. Not painting an entire side of a 100 footer also saved him a used 90's Catalina 30 price wise..;);)

My own boat is painted with Awlcraft 2000 but if I were to do it today I would have used Imron MS-600. While I really love my Awlcraft I have seen some recent MS-600 jobs out of Morris & New England Fiberglass that look simply amazing.

For a decks or non-skid areas I'd likely still opt for Awlgrip but for the top sides I would use a two part acrylic urethane like Awlcraft 2000 or Imron MS-600. I have owned Awlgriped boats before and it is the reason I now have an Awlcraft painted vessel.

Repairability and buffability are big bonuses with any paint..
Ditto here ... I spent the price of a 90's C30+ doing the topsides in Awlcraft 2000 and the deck in Awlgrip ... $300 per foot is more than reasonable for topsides IMO. My problem was that after the topsides were done, the deck looked 30 years old ... so *all* the hardware including the ports came off, the OEM non skid sanded/ground off stress cracks and dings and old hardware holes filled ... etc etc ... for $$$ even though I did the hardware R&R myself.

The result is the newest looking C30 on the planet. :) Odd when a 1975 C30 attracts a crowd in every marina she visits ... the 2009 Sabre Express Cruiser does not get the attention the C30 does.

I do use the Awlcare stuff. Compared to the investment in the paint, why even consider something else?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.