Need help finding a trailer sailor to fit my needs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
I need some help finding which makes/models of trailer sailors will work for me in the 20-23ft range. I live in Falmouth on Cape Cod and plan on using it for cruising in nantucket sound and buzzards bay mostly, with some overnight trips. My vehicle has a 5000lb towing capacity, though i want something substantically lighter and something that is not difficult to setup with one person. I prefer a swing keel so that I could use shallower ramps and beach it. I would like it to sleep atleast 2 comfortably and have a head (portable is ok).

I was looking at an 83 Hunter 20 sloop, but want to hear about some other makes/models to compare it to.

Thanks,
Mitch
 
Jul 24, 2005
261
MacGregor Mac26D Richardson, TX; Dana Point, CA
MacGregor 26S if fun as a starter boat... big enough for weekend and week long family jaunts.... There's others.... :>

--jerry
 

Eric M

.
Sep 30, 2008
159
Island Packet 35 Jacksonville
Mitch,

There are nearly countless options for trailer sailors that would fit your needs. One good place to check out lots of different sailboats is at a local sailing club. Ask around at your local marina retailers to find one in your area. You may be surprised at how many members would be more than willing to take you for a ride to check out their boat.
One more piece of advice since I see you mention an older boat you are considering. If at all possible try to arrange for a test sail on the boat with the current owner prior to purchase. As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words and seeing all the pieces together and working will save you both a lot of frustration if you are left to try to figure it out on your own. In addition, it will reveal that piece that is missing or broken. Sailboats cost lots and lots more as pieces than they do as a whole boat and with older boats some pieces can be more difficult to find.
 
Jan 24, 2005
4,881
Oday 222 Dighton, Ma.
I need some help finding which makes/models of trailer sailors will work for me in the 20-23ft range. I live in Falmouth on Cape Cod and plan on using it for cruising in nantucket sound and buzzards bay mostly, with some overnight trips. My vehicle has a 5000lb towing capacity, though i want something substantically lighter and something that is not difficult to setup with one person. I prefer a swing keel so that I could use shallower ramps and beach it. I would like it to sleep atleast 2 comfortably and have a head (portable is ok).

I was looking at an 83 Hunter 20 sloop, but want to hear about some other makes/models to compare it to.

Thanks,
Mitch
Mitch,
The only thing that comes close to what you're looking for is an O'Day 222 on a roller trailer. The 222s have a keel centerboard which is different than a swing keel. They're really hard to come by right now because they didn't build much more the 300 in Fall River. I used to trailer my 222 years ago and raise the mast myself with the aid of a mast crotch that I built. I used a single sheave block on the bow plate with a 60' 3/8" braid line hooked to the Jib Halyard. I could get the mast up or down in about 20 minutes. The Load-Rite Roller trailer that came with my boat would allow me to launch my boat with ease without having to swamp the trailer. Retrieval was simple too. I trailered my boat for about 8 years in a row. I used to put in at Mattapoisett and sail through Wood's Hole to the Vineyard, or cross the bay and head up to Cuttyhunk I. Two people would be about as many as you would want to accommodate on this boat though. It can sleep four, but four is really too crowded for a boat that size. The first two pics show how I used to get the mast up back then, and the last two pics show how I do it today with the aid of a Gin Pole. If you're not going to have a roller furler, you can get the mast up without the Gin Pole very easy and fast with the aid of a mast holding device and the sheave and rope. The mast only weighs about 65 LBS and is easy to man handle. Since I've had my CDI Roller furler, I had to go to the Gin Pole, which is a little slower, but my boat has bottom paint now, and I use a mooring at our club. Also, I'm 20 years older now and can no longer trailer sail.
Joe
 

Attachments

Nov 6, 2007
32
hunter 18.5 sandhills of west texas
mitch, i'm certainly no expert, but i've got a little time to kill right now, so let me take a stab at this since we've just been through a similar situation fairly recently.
let's see. look's like you're where we were just a year or two back, though you're looking for just a little more pocket cruiser than we were, since your lakes/bays are much larger than ours and we were limited (by driveway space) to less than 20':

your needs:
20-23' - <5,000# - easy, one person set-up - works on shallow ramps (swing keel) - sleeps at least 2 'comfortably' - has a head.

sounds like what most of want in a trailerable sailboat, size perhaps being the single-most limiting factor (if not cost). my advice, for whatever it's worth is to start by going to sailingtexas.com and look in the 'search' area for ALL the boats on the site, even if they've been sold. there are other sites, but this one is numero uno for the initial look-see (again, imho), for pix and data galore on just about every boat available that would fit your needs, and they're not just Texas boats. with that done - and you'll be taking notes on stickies so you can look at them whilst shopping for your new pocket cruiser, right? - you can be taking all of our advice (and leads!) and probably find what you want and/or truly need pretty quickly.
example: i had the same criteria for my search, but i actually had given up on finding one out here in the desert (until i literally tripped over the trailer tongue one night). what we eventually bought was hiding out behind an rv dealership. it was a trade-in that nobody wanted, so naturally it became ours. logic be damned. you know how it is. BUT, i've learned much since then, and a lot of that was on this site.
what we got was a 1988 hunter 18.5 wing keel (fixed, about 2' draft), in fairly good shape, with great sails and spectacular rigging and upgrades. if i had to duplicate it from scratch, even sourcing some used parts, it'd cost me about $10k right now - it's worth at least $4-5k right now, as it sits. we paid literally nothing for it, just got it in the motorhome deal. with all the wheeling and dealing, both the dealer and i feel it added about $1k to the price of our motorhome, and i've bought half a dozen rv's so i know that market very, very well, so the $1k is just about right. so deals are aplenty, and we were in a booming oil economy at the time down here, so your finds should be near-unbelievable up your way. we usually do not get deals in west texas on anything, unless we're in a severe recession. we are just whipping posts to the retailers of the world here.

with your specs in mind, the hunter is a nice little boat (as is ours), if maybe not the fastest or absolute 'best' available. many were sold so parts are out there, but i'm not 'brand-centric' so others 'might' be more available on the general market that 'might' suit your needs better than just taking the first hunter that comes along, though the little hunters (again, imho) are very fine trailer sailors.

first thing: how much do you really want to invest in your project? okay, cut that maybe in half, since you'll be needing the rest for all kinds of things post-purchase. try to think of ALL the expenses of getting your first year of sailing in your new or new/old boat under your belt. after all, if you buy it and then don't have anything left to sail with (fuel, food, lodging, taxes, licenses, pfd's, outboard tlc, sail fixes, possible swing keel work, lighting, slip fees, storage (God forbid), bumps and bruises, new magma grill, etc.) then you're just going to have a garage queen, and woe be to you whomever it puts out - like the missus. we don't call them 'admirals' for nuthin'! pay attention to that last statement very, very carefully. just lookin' out for ya'.
if you're new to sailing, get some nice folks to take you out. down here in Texas, we'll happily drive a couple hundred miles (one-way) just to take somebody out on our boats, and then we'll (also) happily cruise on over to somebody else we know (or don't, we're not shy down here) and see if they'll take you out as well. kansas, colorado, arizona, new mexico, oklahoma, arkansas and louisiana are exactly the same way, and i'm guessing where there's real water, like where you live, the folks are just as friendly. dunno.
one thing i've picked up from your original post is that you would seem to be more a 'cruiser' (like us) than a 'racer,' though i'm sure you'd be up for a regatta now and then with the right boat, or one that over time you felt comfortable enough with to take around the buoys. here's some hopefully, helpful pointers.

- look for a boat with lots of company (many sold), like the catalina 22 or equivalent
- look for a pop-top, especially if you're taller than my 5'8" as they're handy, some hunters and the cat 22 and 25, lagunas, some macgregors, o'days, rhodes 22, etc. have them. very nice to have. claustrophobia ain't my favorite thing on a boat.
- make sure the weight is WELL within your tow vehicle's ability to pull it out of a STEEP ramp after a hot, tiring afternoon or weekend of sailing. not all ramps are shallow. though you may be in a miracle area with no droughts. Texas (nor any southwestern state) does NOT fall into that category. we have major shifts in water levels going on all the time.
- make sure the thing's set up for single handing in the cockpit and suitable for you and your physical needs. check the coaming by sitting in it, make sure the rake of the seat back suits you.
- sails and rigging in good visible shape, interior not nasty, bilge (and KEEL BOLTS) not rotted or rusted out. electrics done well, all rope not thready, wire not splayed, turnbuckles nice and shiny, or at least decent.
- you can (and should) buy a new porta-potty. the teak doesn't have to be great looking, just in good shape. it does turn gray with use and exposure, you know. walk on the topdecks, just like you would when sailing (but do use proper shoes!) checking for soft spots. look down the sides for any peeling, cracking, warping, repairs, etc. check the keel area for weirdness. check the trailer. try to move each wheel from side to side (on top of each wheel - pushing, pulling) checking for bearing wear. does the trailor have bearing buddies? is the outboard in one piece or in boxes. etc.
- now, all of that's mainly just visual checking and mostly also cosmetic, including condition of boat paint and trailer paint. they're maintenance things you can do over time (much time, unfortunately or fortunately, however you look at it), but the real devil's in the details that might be better left to a real, live boat surveyor. if the boat's pretty darned clean everywhere, and there aren't any 'stories' from the owner, you might be fine with, say, a $2,000 boat you'd take a chance with. (a good trailer or a great set of sails is just about worth the risk there.) your hunter or maybe a decent cat 22 or whatever. but if you're looking at a $7-10k boat, like a nice rhodes 22 (which has ONE FINE camping set-up, plus a neat mast, cabin layout, etc.) or something similar, you might want to have it checked if you're spending a bunch of dinero, amigo.

all this stuff is obvious, and many, many other folks here can offer deeper, more applicable insights, and i'm sure they will. but having just gone through this sort of purchase, i thought i'd add a couple cents of common sense into the mix.

now, specifically looking at your hunter 22, take a look on this site, under 'boat info' and then 'sailboat info' then 'hunter 20 owner reviews' and finally 'arthur hicks' for a great review of your exact boat. there are many other reviews of your boat there as well. they're telling, so read every single review. they show the good, bad and ugly. just the way you'd want a real salesman to help you out. your GOOD NEWS is that it looks like you have a very lightweight, easily trailered (and launched AND retrieved), camp-able, reasonable, POP-TOP boat already located. does it measure up to others in its class? dunno. the condition of it, against the asking price (which should probably be lower) might get you a very nice purchase.

if you do get it and don't like it, you could always trade me for a great hunter 18.5. even meet you half-way. HA!

yes, this is a longggg post, but it's a question that gets asked just about every day somewhere online, so i figured i'd take a stab at it since i had some time, and i wasn't trying to hog the space or tick anybody off, and as i said, i'd just sort of been through just about exactly the same thing not too long ago.

jack b :) in midland, tx usa
 
Last edited:
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
MacGregor 26S if fun as a starter boat... big enough for weekend and week long family jaunts.... There's others.... :>

--jerry
Its a nice boat but to big and pricey for my needs.....maybe a smaller, older model though....
 
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
Mitch,

There are nearly countless options for trailer sailors that would fit your needs. One good place to check out lots of different sailboats is at a local sailing club. Ask around at your local marina retailers to find one in your area. You may be surprised at how many members would be more than willing to take you for a ride to check out their boat.
One more piece of advice since I see you mention an older boat you are considering. If at all possible try to arrange for a test sail on the boat with the current owner prior to purchase. As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words and seeing all the pieces together and working will save you both a lot of frustration if you are left to try to figure it out on your own. In addition, it will reveal that piece that is missing or broken. Sailboats cost lots and lots more as pieces than they do as a whole boat and with older boats some pieces can be more difficult to find.
I was definitely going to have the boat setup so I could see it in action, and I would request a seatrial...the problem is that I am on cape cod and theres alot of ice in the water right now! So it might be hard to get done....
 
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
jack b :) in midland, tx usa
Wow, what a write up (too long to quote it)! I am looking for a well used boat, but in decent shape overall with no structural problems. I've grown up boating so I am no stranger to boats, albeit mostly in powerboats, and can do most repairs myself (except sails) although I do know exactly what you mean by all the little expenses adding up. Boat will be stored at work on trailer, no problems with needing to store or moore it. I would like to get a surveyor, but its close to the point where I feel like the investment may not need it.....The guy is asking $3k for boat with a good hull, sails and a trailer...though a few issues that I think I can address. I guess my price range is <$4k. I had already read the info and reviews on the boat and found them mostly favorable, and Hick's review was especially helpful (bow pulpit is a great idea). I live on cape cod, a bit far from you, but thanks for the ride offer!
 
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
Mitch,
The only thing that comes close to what you're looking for is an O'Day 222 on a roller trailer. The 222s have a keel centerboard which is different than a swing keel. They're really hard to come by right now because they didn't build much more the 300 in Fall River. I used to trailer my 222 years ago and raise the mast myself with the aid of a mast crotch that I built. I used a single sheave block on the bow plate with a 60' 3/8" braid line hooked to the Jib Halyard. I could get the mast up or down in about 20 minutes. The Load-Rite Roller trailer that came with my boat would allow me to launch my boat with ease without having to swamp the trailer. Retrieval was simple too. I trailered my boat for about 8 years in a row. I used to put in at Mattapoisett and sail through Wood's Hole to the Vineyard, or cross the bay and head up to Cuttyhunk I. Two people would be about as many as you would want to accommodate on this boat though. It can sleep four, but four is really too crowded for a boat that size. The first two pics show how I used to get the mast up back then, and the last two pics show how I do it today with the aid of a Gin Pole. If you're not going to have a roller furler, you can get the mast up without the Gin Pole very easy and fast with the aid of a mast holding device and the sheave and rope. The mast only weighs about 65 LBS and is easy to man handle. Since I've had my CDI Roller furler, I had to go to the Gin Pole, which is a little slower, but my boat has bottom paint now, and I use a mooring at our club. Also, I'm 20 years older now and can no longer trailer sail.
Joe
Thanks for the pics, I will check the Oday 22 out!
 
Jan 24, 2005
4,881
Oday 222 Dighton, Ma.
Mitch,
I neglected to mention the O'Day 22 which is a different model than the 222, but this boat would also be a good choice for a small cruising sailboat for trailering. The 22 has a nice strong hull that can take a roller trailer also. You're more likely to find one of these because O'Day built more of them. I'm told that O'Day built some of their 22's with keel/centerboards. I've never had the opportunity to see one, but I'm guessing that the upwind performance would be a little better than their stubby keel model. However, both models are pretty decent cruising sailboats, I think. The 222's have rudder blade problems and I really do not recall anyone having the same issue with the O'Day 22, but I could be wrong on that.
Joe
 
Jan 2, 2008
547
Hunter 33 (Cherubini design Forked River, Barnegat Bay, NJ
Don't overlook the old MacGregor 25

It seems to meet many, if not all of your criteria.

At 3000 lbs for boat and trailer it is light. And certainly not overbuilt.

Swing keel with 2' to 6' draft.

Roomy with private-ish head area. Could sleep 4 to 6.

Sails surprisingly well. I've had mine for 3 years and sailed it twice. My friend used it all last season so I got in a day sail last fall and was impressed with it's balance. I would be tempted to keep it but with a Hunter 260 sitting next to it in the yard it just doesn't make a lot of sense. I think I will be sorry to see it go

Great balance of cockpit and interior.

Very moderately priced. depending on year, condition and equipment I see them in a range of $2500 to $5000 with trailer.
 
Nov 6, 2007
32
hunter 18.5 sandhills of west texas
mitch, if you think he's for real, have your seller knock a 'bit' off for whatever work it visibly needs - he'll understand - take out the cash, and take that puppy home! if you don't like it within a reasonable amount of time, just sell it as it sounds like a very good bet that you'd get your money back on it (or more, in sailing season). with the work done to your expectations, it sounds like a perfect starter boat for the parameters you've set, but i durn shur wouldn't want to live on it for more than a coupla nights at a time - max. how's the rest of your crew see it?
jack b :) in midland, tx usa
 
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
Mitch,
I had this site saved for when I was looking For my 26D. Check it out.

http://www.shortypen.com/boats/pocket/advice.htm

Bob
Really good writeup, thanks! I had been trying to figure out what all the keel differences were.

My crew is small, most likely just me and my girlfriend and a guest or two at max.

The Macgregor 25 would be a great boat, but not sure if I want to deal with that much boat right now (my self-impossed limit for boat/trailer/motor is about $3k). Might be better to start off simpler so as to get my skills honed.
 
Jan 22, 2008
507
Catalina 310 278 Lyndeborough NH
Experience with O'Day 19

I need some help finding which makes/models of trailer sailors will work for me in the 20-23ft range. I live in Falmouth on Cape Cod and plan on using it for cruising in nantucket sound and buzzards bay mostly, with some overnight trips. My vehicle has a 5000lb towing capacity, though i want something substantically lighter and something that is not difficult to setup with one person. I prefer a swing keel so that I could use shallower ramps and beach it. I would like it to sleep atleast 2 comfortably and have a head (portable is ok).

I was looking at an 83 Hunter 20 sloop, but want to hear about some other makes/models to compare it to.

Thanks,
Mitch
Mitch,

I purchased an '83 O'Day 19 two years ago. It is a downsized version of the O'Day 22. (The O'day 192 and 222 are model upgrades with more space under the cockpit for the berths.) I paid $1600 on eBay from one of the charity auction sellers. I was confident that at the price (and the condition viewed in the photos) that I would be able to handle anything that might be wrong with it. My wife and I have sailed it the past two seasons Boston Harbor, Portsmouth Harbor, and Lake Champlain with very minor "adjustments".

It started life on the Hudson River then was given to new owners as a wedding present by their uncle. They have a cottage just north of you in Pocasset and were tired of waiting for a mooring. In spite of the fact that they could see the town launch ramp from their front door and the O'Day was on a trailer with rollers, they never put it in the water. So they donated it to a charity organization that auctioned it on eBay.

So COST can be VERY reasonable. Trailering means I can go anywhere.

Once we were caught at low tide in Little Harbor (Portsmouth NH) using the Odiorne State Park launch ramp. We motored up the remaining little channel (using an electric trolling motor) to the lauch ramp. The concrete portion of the ramp ended well before the low water mark. We could have waited a few hours for the tide to come back in, but instead backed my Jeep to the end of the concrete, unhooked the trailer pushing it into the water but tethered to a strap. Since the trailer had rollers, we could winch the boat onto the trailer with little effort. The Jeep in low range pulled the boat and trailer up the mud to the concrete area. The only thing I wished I had then was a wheel under the trailer tongue.

PROS:
This model (O'Day 19) has a swing centerboard and a short weighted keel. Draft is 12 inches. I could launch anywhere, beach anywhere. It weighs 1400 lbs and can be towed by most vehicles with a type II rated hitch. My Jeep looses only 2 miles/gal on the highway when towing.

The cockpit is large enough for four adults for a day cruise. We did this often. Sleeping arrangements are "camping for two". Since we day-sail, this was never a problem. The cabin was for storage. But for watching the fireworks from the water in Burlington VT, we comfortably had six adults. But most of the time, I enjoyed either being by myself or with my wife. One can be social or seek solitude depending on the situation.

The trailer can be a simple one readily available for motor boats. Keeps the cost down. Go with rollers if possible.

The boat can easily be propelled by a small outboard or even simpler by an electric trolling motor. Choose by your needs for wind and current. I alternate depending on the location.

I can single-handedly raise and rig the mast with no special assistance. I use the jib halyard and walk the mast up. I'm 57 and in "average" shape for my age.

CONS:
Size - overnighting would be like sleeping in a tent. I can do it, but there is the "Admiral" who prefers a real bed - it's actually mostly for back support reasons.

Fair Weather Sailing - my wife is not yet comfortable with the rolling motion when the winds are above 15 knots. The keel weight of the O'Day 19 is not considered self-righting. So it is best as a fair-weather boat when the crew is inexperienced.

FOOT-ITIS:
The 19 foot size is very good and convenient for someone who wants to primarily day-sail and be able to go anywhere at the spur of the moment with up to 4 people. Overnighting is like camping.

In August, my friend (he and his wife were our regular sailing companions) purchased a '73 Ensenada 20. Amazing how much of a difference one foot in length and different layout will make. They ARE very much a couple who would overnight in the boat and are our age. The interior of the boat needed significant repair but well within my friend's skills. He also modified the insides to meet his needs.

This October I purchased a Catalina Capri 22 (wing keel) from eBay to address the needs for a little more space (for socializing) and stability with a fixed keel. The original owner had died. His friend received the boat but was not an active sailor. It was donated t a charity and auctioned on eBay. I got it for $1400. It had no trailer but I modified the one for my O'Day to get it home. Condition - ready to go back into the water.

OBSERVATIONS:
Pulling it back from New Haven CT to southern NH went very smoothly. It weighs 2200 lbs. The keel boat (2' 8" draft) sits up higher but most of the weight is in the keel. I will be reworking the trailer to lower the boat and reattach the rollers.

The experience we had at Odiorne State Park launch ramp convinced me that I could launch and retrieve a keel boat from my favorite launch ramps (but not from Odiorne's ramp). Yesterday I checked out the ramp at Dover Point on the Piscataqua River near Great Bay during low tide. Yes, I want those rollers back on!

SUMMARY:
Within your price range, you can purchase a reasonable sailboat, trailer, and motor. The more work you are comfortable doing, the better the deal you can get. My two boats needed basically to be cleaned because they have sat unused for a few seasons. But other than replacing a fitting or two, both were ready to go into the water the day I picked them up.

Boat yards often have boats that the owners have "abandoned" and stopped paying the yard fees. Often, you can get a very good deal assuming the yard owner has gained possession of the tittle.

EBay has worked out very well for me. My friend found his on Craig's List. He is happy.

If you are unsure about your "repair" abilities, then by all means look for a boat using a registered surveyor.

AND YES, the Admiral has stated that the O'Day 19 be sold this Spring (a pre-announcement in case anyone might be interested). I still have my Paceship P-17 for those "thin water" lakes...

John
 
  • Like
Likes: 1 person

Timo42

.
Mar 26, 2007
1,042
Venture 22 Marina del Rey
Have to suggest the Venture/Macgregor 22-2, like the 25 but 3' shorter, given your price range and size. 525lb swing keel, make sure you get one with a cast keel, not the earlier composite, poptop, portapotty in front of a bulkhead for a little privacy, room for 2 to sleep, easy to trailer and rig, parts available, lots of them out there, easy to sail. There are guys on this coast who take them to the Channel Islands and Catalina all the time, I am going to this summer:dance: Probably the least expensive boat you are going to find. The interior is minimal, it does have a molded liner, but you can modify it to fit your needs without worrying about hurting resale value. I paid $800 for mine with a new trailer and sailed it the next weekend. I have done a lot to it since, but my wife still thinks of it as an $800 boat;) If she ever added it all up :eek:. Tim
 
Nov 6, 2007
32
hunter 18.5 sandhills of west texas
mitch, whether you get your hunter or one of the above mentioned boats, you might pay some attention to what tim just said in the last couple of sentences about what he spent, and what his wife thinks he's spent. it's real important. take it from another trailer-sailor who knows how that works, as it can be a real 'peace' keeper. jack b ;-)
 
Jan 15, 2009
12
2 ... Falmouth
Thanks for the info all! I think I will keep this boat in mind but keep searching. I'll be sure to check out the catalina 22, O'day 19, 22 and macgregor 22 as well. A 22 would be a great size if I can find one for a reasonable cost as I am sure I will get two footisitis with a 19 or 20fter especially since the cockpit on the boat I looked at wasn't very large. Thanks to everyone who contributed!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.