How to prevent mildew during winter

Oct 6, 2007
1,184
Hunter H30 1982 Chicago IL
Venting and desiccant... I think the math does not work as you think. Is there still desiccant in the spring, when you open the boat? But it works because you are not in a damp climate, compared to coastal areas with ocean-warmed water. In boats with wet bilges and warm water, the desiccant would only last a few weeks or a month. Yup, tested that. Basically, you are drying the great outdoors, if there are vents.

Relative humidity in Seattle is about 85-90% through the winter. Very high. Think fog inside the boat some nights! Different. It is also considerably warmer, meaning the air holds more water at a given RH.

Coastal MD and coastal Maine are about 80% RH. Chicago is colder and about 75% RH.

Also, mold does not grow when it is sub-freezing. Nothing does. IME, it is a spring thing.

Also, the OP keeps his boat in the water. That makes a BIG difference, since any water in the bilge will condense in the cold cabin(the water is considerably warmer than the air).

Complicated.
This is why I specifically stated that this approach works for the Great Lakes and upper mid-west. Not everywhere. I also noted variables such as in water vs on the hard storage and covered vs uncovered.

The math works exactly as I think. In this climate. From October through April or mid-May. And yes, there is still desiccant left in the spring. As you alluded to, comparing relative humidity without consideration of temperature does not express absolute humidity or actual moisture in the air. Cold winter air in Chicago is extremely dry. Summer is the opposite, often oppressively humid. That‘s when venting and desiccant would indeed be a futile combination, but that’s not when we store our boats here. Yeh, complicated.

I am aware that the OP is in the PNW, much of which is uniquely classified a cold rain forest, and I also see that people responded from coast to coast. Some are in the same climate. Others are not. It’s a national forum, international actually, and that’s why I took the time to respond. Maybe that was a waste of time.
 
Mar 26, 2011
4,063
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
I'm sorry for the way I came off. I should also hav
This is why I specifically stated that this approach works for the Great Lakes and upper mid-west. Not everywhere. I also noted variables such as in water vs on the hard storage and covered vs uncovered.

The math works exactly as I think. In this climate. From October through April or mid-May. And yes, there is still desiccant left in the spring. As you alluded to, comparing relative humidity without consideration of temperature does not express absolute humidity or actual moisture in the air. Cold winter air in Chicago is extremely dry. Summer is the opposite, often oppressively humid. That‘s when venting and desiccant would indeed be a futile combination, but that’s not when we store our boats here. Yeh, complicated.

I am aware that the OP is in the PNW, much of which is uniquely classified a cold rain forest, and I also see that people responded from coast to coast. Some are in the same climate. Others are not. It’s a national forum, international actually, and that’s why I took the time to respond. Maybe that was a waste of time.
I'm sorry I came across that way. I also should have been more clear.

It is likely the boat would have been even drier if you had just sealed it completely and let the desiccant do its job, without venting in outside air. The equilibrium RH over CaCl2 is 20-30%, vs. outside air at 75%. Once the CaCl2 has dried the boat, all the vent does is bring in more moist air. It's not as though you can control which days the vent is active. Put another way, if the CaCl2 is working at all, the humidity inside the boat will always be incrementally lower than the humidity outside the boat, even as the temperature drops. Think Monday vs. Tuesday., not month-to-month. True? If not, then more ventilation is a better answer. I doubt that. That said, in Chicago on the hard, I think most people successfully just ventilate. As you say, the winter is not that humid.

But if you still have Ca Cl2 left, it is working well enough. The vents are small enough. You could try sealing the vents, and measuring if there is more, or less, CaCl2 remaining. I'm betting there would be more, that's all.
 
Last edited:
Oct 6, 2007
1,184
Hunter H30 1982 Chicago IL
I'm sorry for the way I came off. I should also hav

e been more clear.

It is likely the boat would have been even drier if you had just sealed it completely and let the desiccant do its job, without venting in outside air. The equilibrium RH over CaCl2 is 20-30%, vs. outside air at 75%. Once the CaCl2 has dried the boat, all the vent does is bring in more moist air. It's not as though you can control which days the vent is active. Put another way, if the CaCl2 is working at all, the humidity inside the boat will always be incrementally lower than the humidity outside the boat, even as the temperature drops. Think Monday vs. Tuesday., not month-to-month. True? If not, then more ventilation is a better answer. I doubt that. That said, in Chicago on the hard, I think most people successfully just ventilate. As you say, the winter is not that humid.

But if you still have Ca Cl2 left, it is working well enough. The vents are small enough. You could try sealing the vents, and measuring if there is more, or less, CaCl2 remaining. I'm betting there would be more, that's all.
Sounds good in theory, and it’s technically correct in an ideal situation, but it has not been my experience with this boat in this climate.

The years when I attempted to completely seal the boat and rely on calcium chloride desiccant only, I ended up with a surprising amount of condensation in the bilge and a bilge pump sitting in a block of ice. Same, worse actually, with ventilation alone. Lazarettes that are not isolated from the cabin are a significant obstacle to a complete seal while the rapid extreme temperature and humidity swings typical in this climate produce condensation far faster inside a solid glass hull than ventilation alone can mitigate. In the spring and fall, even occasionally in mid-winter, we can have three or four days of warm, humid weather and then be slammed with blizzard conditions 24 hours later. Average temperature and humidity data gloss over the extremes.

This combination approach came about through years of trial and error and it works for me in this climate.