Trouble keeping Catalina 16.5 on the trailer

rcintx

.
Apr 13, 2026
4
Catalina 16.5 Trailer
Hi all,

First post! I've had a Catalina 16.5 for about a year now. The closest body of water to me is 45-60 minutes away. I've made the trip a couple of times but it is nerve wracking. My Catalina 16.5 is lightweight and bounces all around the trailer. I have tried strapping it down several different ways and I've gotten it better, but it still needs to be adjusted on the trailer every 20-30 minutes. Any tips on strapping? Do I need to move the bunks or add goal posts? Any advice would be great. I'd love to sail more often but dread the trip.
 

pgandw

.
Oct 14, 2023
242
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Yeopim Creek
Just guessing that the trailer is built for heavier loads. But let's start with the easy stuff first.

- boat must be tied DOWN to trailer at both bow and at bunks. A horizontal pull on the bow eye is needed to retrieve the boat from the water, a downward pull is stop the bow from lifting from the trailer once the boat is fully on the trailer. Usually the height of the winch can be set to achieve both, but if you can't get the winch height adjusted correctly, rig a strap or line to tie the bow eye down.

- A strap across the boat and down to the trailer frame on both sides at the rear end of the bunks is usually sufficient along with the bow eye. Even better is angling the rear strap inwards as it comes down to the frame on the 2 sides. Note that you don't want to over-tension this strap, but you want it to be tight enough to hold the boat to the bunks when the trailer bounces. Also, don't tie the transom down unless your trailer bunks extend all the way to the stern.

- bunk height should be adjusted to be as low as possible while leaving room for the keel to be on the keel rollers. If you have no keel or stub, and you have a dagger board instead of a centerboard, disregard this paragraph. Your centerboard/lifting keel should be carried by a roller on the trailer, and not by the boat hull. So part of the launch routine is pulling the centerboard up, and part of retrieval is lowering the centerboard to the trailer. Don't ask me how this became ingrained in my memory! In my case, the hull hangs out over the wheel fenders, which limits how low the bunks can be. Even with 2" clearance, I had to put carpet on the fenders to prevent hull to metal contact on the bumps in the road. I can tell they work because I have bottom paint on the carpet to prove it.

- goal posts are very useful for centering the boat during the retrieval in any kind of cross wind, but are pretty useless otherwise. Once you get a sailboat most of the way on, the maximum beam is already through the goal posts and the posts do nothing. But the further back you put the posts on the trailer, the more leverage they have during retrieval. Some prefer side boards to goal posts. Side boards would be better where the hull bottom is flat and there is no keel.

- improve the ride on the trailer by setting tire inflation correctly. This will require knowing the weight on the trailer tires. CAT scales cost $20/weighing, interstate weigh stations work if there is no truck traffic present. ST tires (trailer tires) have manufacturers minimum tire pressure charts for a given load (lbs) and tire size. Add 10% and use that as your tire pressure - you do check tire pressure before every trip? Highly recommended if you don't.

- slow down over bumpy roads, and avoid bad roads when possible. When trailering from North Carolina to Connecticut, I have learned the hard way to go way around New York City - the roads are that bad. My mast ended up jumping up out of the carrier on a terrible NYC freeway during rush hour. What a scary mess. Don't be me. Make sure the mast and its trailering supports are properly tied down, too.

- finally, make sure your trailer springs and frame are in decent shape - no cracked spring leaves or hangers, no cracked welds in the frame.

hope this helps
Fred W
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Sweet P
 
Oct 13, 2020
206
catalina C-22 4980 channel islands CA
I use two 1500 # ratcheting tie down straps on my c22. one across the stern and one at the bow.
Dano
 
  • Like
Likes: rcintx
Sep 24, 2018
4,603
Catalina 30 MKIII Chicago
1" straps stretch. Switching to some heavy duty straps will make a noticeable difference. It's a good idea to check your straps after a few miles of travel.

Adjusting tire pressure up or down might help.

I've also moved the bow support forward (which in turn brings the boat forward) on pretty much every sailboat trailer I've owned. This reduces the chance of the trailer swaying back and forth.
 
  • Like
Likes: rcintx

rcintx

.
Apr 13, 2026
4
Catalina 16.5 Trailer
All great things for me to look at. I'll pull the boat/trailer out of the shop this weekend and take some pictures. That might show some obvious issues. I have been using 1" straps and they will be tight (tighter than I want them) and 20 miles later be very loose. I'll find some heavier duty ones. I'll have to check on the tire pressure as well. Thank you all for the replies!
 
Jan 19, 2010
12,968
Hobie 16 & Rhodes 22 Skeeter Charleston
Is the trailer pulling straight or swaying side-to-side when you drive. If it is swaying, you need MORE weight on the trailer tongue. Sometimes as little as 50# makes all the difference in the ride. You can shift weight around in the boat but sometimes a more permanent solution is to slide the winch assembly forward a few inches... If you have some slack in your winch assembly, loosen the nuts on the U-bold (see left red arrow) and slide the winch forward a few inches. Then secure it all and take your boat for a ride and see if it drives smoother.

1776267031870.png
 

rcintx

.
Apr 13, 2026
4
Catalina 16.5 Trailer
Thats a good idea. I don't "think" that it is swaying side to side but the problem is more that the boat and trailer are bouncing and the boat slides off to the side. When I pull it out I'll take it for a spin and pay closer attention. Maybe it is swaying more than I think it is. Thank you for the recommendation.
 
  • Like
Likes: rgranger

pgandw

.
Oct 14, 2023
242
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Yeopim Creek
It is equally possible on many trailers (like the one pictured) to move the axle forward or backward a few inches. I did this on a dual axle trailer for my ODay 25 which had too light a tongue weight when it came from the dealer (less than 100lbs). A rough order of magnitude would be 100lbs tongue weight for your Catalina 16ft (8-10% of boat and trailer weight). If there is room, moving the winch stand would be preferred. If you move the axle, measure the diagonal to a center point forward on the trailer to make sure the axle stays square to the frame.

Fred W
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Sweet P
 

JBP-PA

.
Apr 29, 2022
804
Jeanneau Tonic 23 Erie, PA
All great things for me to look at. I'll pull the boat/trailer out of the shop this weekend and take some pictures. That might show some obvious issues. I have been using 1" straps and they will be tight (tighter than I want them) and 20 miles later be very loose. I'll find some heavier duty ones. I'll have to check on the tire pressure as well. Thank you all for the replies!
Yea, if your straps work loose, you need better straps. They should stay tight.
 
Jan 19, 2010
12,968
Hobie 16 & Rhodes 22 Skeeter Charleston
bouncing and the boat slides off to the side.
I've never trailered that small of a boat. The smallest I have trailered is a 22'. BUT... even those had U-bolts in the transom that I could put a ratchet strap on and really tighten it down. There was no way short of me rolling the trailer that my boat was going to slide off. If you don't have U-bolts in the transom... you should add some. They are only $20. Put a good backing plate behind the U-bolt.

1776286138217.png
1776286370937.png
 
Sep 24, 2018
4,603
Catalina 30 MKIII Chicago
Yea, if your straps work loose, you need better straps. They should stay tight.
I've experienced what the OP is describing when I used two 10' straps tied together (in series) on a 1300lbs 19' boat. I believe they end up stretching as the boat goes over bumps. It results in what feels like the boat is moving around. However, when you go to check the straps, they are almost always tight. I was pretty surprised that going to a 3" strap made a noticeable difference. I haven't tried a 1.5" or 2" strap as I had a 3" on hand.

@rcintx If you have multiple 1" straps, you could try adding more. On my 19' and 25', I used one over the bow area and one over the cockpit coamings. I'm not sure if adjusting tire pressure up or down will help but it's worth a try.
I've never trailered that small of a boat. The smallest I have trailered is a 22'. BUT... even those had U-bolts in the transom that I could put a ratchet strap on and really tighten it down. There was no way short of me rolling the trailer that my boat was going to slide off. If you don't have U-bolts in the transom... you should add some. They are only $20. Put a good backing plate behind the U-bolt.

View attachment 237333View attachment 237334
For power boats this is great but the transom on most sailboats hangs off too far to do much good. For the OP's small boat it might work, especially if the boat is moved forward on the trailer
 
Jan 19, 2010
12,968
Hobie 16 & Rhodes 22 Skeeter Charleston
For power boats this is great but the transom on most sailboats hangs off too far to do much good. For the OP's small boat it might work, especially if the boat is moved forward on the trailer
Well.... I've owned a two different Magregor 21s a Macgregor 22, a Coronado 23 a Coronado 25, a Balboa 26, a Rhodes 22 (still have this one) and a Hunter 26. All of those boats had U- bolts on or near the transom for tie down. I don't know what the transom loolks like on the OPs boat but I bet there is someplace near the stern where you could place an attachement point with a backing plate.
 

pgandw

.
Oct 14, 2023
242
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 Yeopim Creek
The problem isn't reinforcing the transom - although that would certainly have to be done on my Stuart (ODay) Mariner. The problem is that many sailboat trailers do not have bunks or rollers under the transom. Putting a lot of downward pressure on the transom with no trailer support underneath is asking for trouble - especially for something lightly built like a Catalina 16.5. A strap over the cockpit coamings where there are trailer supports works just as well, especially on smaller sailboats where much lower height on trailer makes it easy to put the strap across.

Fred W
Stuart (ODay) Mariner 19 with a reinforced transom where the motor mount attaches
 
  • Like
Likes: Timm R Oday25
Sep 24, 2018
4,603
Catalina 30 MKIII Chicago
Yea, if your straps work loose, you need better straps. They should stay tight.
The slick straps that feel nice in your hand are more likely to slip than the ones that are more textured. It's all about friction
 
Sep 24, 2018
4,603
Catalina 30 MKIII Chicago
I imagine doubling up on straps would work on a boat of this size and weight. The big 3" truck straps were enough to keep my 25' boat in place.

I'd setup a camera or ask someone to monitor/record the trailer while you're driving to see what it's doing.

I've also towed empty trailers that bounce around like crazy. Perhaps your trailer is built for a heavier load.
 
Last edited:

rcintx

.
Apr 13, 2026
4
Catalina 16.5 Trailer
Pulled her out of the shop this morning to snap some pictures. First up, the bow strap. I'd say it is pretty horizontal. Should I lower it?

IMG_3715.jpg


I also found that the bottom front bunk is loose and almost off. Glad to have found that so I can fix it.
IMG_3716.jpg


Last time I pulled it I strapped the rear end down like this. It helped, but it still moved side to side.
IMG_3717.jpg


Looks like I could pull the boat a little more to the front of the trailer and maybe make use of U bolts as suggested.
IMG_3718.jpg



Any additional thoughts after seeing pictures?
 
Sep 24, 2018
4,603
Catalina 30 MKIII Chicago
I agree with @JBP-PA about strapping methods. I will also say that when it comes to straps, the simple methods are usually more effective.

I'd try moving the bow support forward. It may or may not provide any benefit but it's a pretty easy thing to do.