Hi Noah,
The age old dingy question is almost a religious one. Everyone has their opinion, and each one swears it's the only way.
I can tell you what I have now, after many years of many types. I have a fairly inexpensive 11' PVC inflatable, with high pressure floor. Bought it new online for $430. I have an 8 hp Johnson on the back. For me, this works well, as it is very light and easy to get on deck and deflate/inflate (thanks to the HP floor) in the car, basement etc. The outboard is small enough to get on the stern rail of the big boat, yet large enough to get my wife, daughter and I up on a plane (barley). The key to the cheaper PVC built inflatables, is to stow them out of the sun in the off season or if you are not going to use it for more than two months or so. I supose they don't last long in the Bahama's, down island, Mexico etc, but I'm not down there anymore.
There are many words written on the merrits of the better hypolon material that last much longer, howver you pay more for these boats, both new and used. So, i've taken that tack that I'll keep mine in good condition (out of the sun) for as long as it lasts. If I get 6 year out of it, I'll have gotten my $70/year's worth.
Over many years, I've had ranger minto, 9' boston whaler, metzler, 10' West Marine PVC "Zodiac" (alum floor boards, pain in the neck), 13' hypolon Zodiac (wood floor boards, pain in the neck, TRIED once to take them out)
I'm on year 3 with the PVC inflateable, and love the high pressure floor.
My humble opinion......
Graeme