Wooden Boats - Someone Talk Some Sense Into Me

Jan 25, 2017
147
Macgregor V222 Kentucky Lake
So here we go. I need all the sane sailors (if there is such a thing) particularly those sailing wood boats to help me out here. This past weekend I looked at a pilot sloop, (I assume it's a pilot sloop based on the design but it could be one of the many variations of a pilot sloop and I've seen, and there are many). I've been looking for a project, as if three Sunfish, a Hobie Cat, Thistle, Snark and McGregor V222 aren't enough. My partner and I are looking to partially retire in the next 5 to 10 years and do a little cruising. It's our dream, and as with most dreams, an occasional reality check is necessary.

We always loved the classic pilot sloops but never considered one because, well... their wood. LOL - at least the ones we consider appealing. We live in a 120-year-old wooden house and love it, so it stands to reason our sailboat taste would be similar, classic.

Now before the naysayers start to chime in, let me be clear. I'm looking to talk to sailors who have actually owned or still own a wooden boat. I love this site and have always valued the information I get from it and the people who provide it. That being said... if you've "heard" or "someone told you," with respect please don't comment. Or at the least keep it positive, if you do. Many times I see folks here "punching above their weight class. I'm an experienced sailor and have successfully completed a number of restorations, just not a wood one.

IMG_8024.JPG


Her deck has been glassed over and there doesn't appear to be any water coming from the top side. She appears to be oak and the seams seem more or less tight, though the bilge is pumping out water occasionally and there is a couple of inches of water in the bilge itself, though it doesn't reach the sole.

IMG_8026.JPG

The current owner (the marina manager) has no idea what she is. She was given to him in lieu of slip fees (sad). He said the old man spent his inheritance building her (best guess she was built in the '80s). She appears to be quit overbuild, heavy and solid at least above the waterline.

The interior is pretty bare, though that's kind of what we are looking for, as we could finish to our liking.

IMG_8012.JPG
IMG_8002.JPG


Again, there is no water coming from the ports or above from what I can see and there is a new or nearly new Beta Marine 35 diesel engine with low hours.

The main is nearly new with a new cover. It appears to be missing its headsails though they are looking for them now.

There is no head, but it's plumbed for the galley sink so there is a holding tank somewhere. ALL THAT BEING SAID - the price is right. We have the desire and don't need a lot of encouragement to pull the trigger. It would be a multi-year project, but something we could use as a "lake cabin" while we work on her. It seems to me the old woodies are a little more forgiving when "building out the interior. In other words, many of the same techniques used with tradition "home wood construction" would apply. "So we want the companion stairs here, just build them there the way we want."
"Want a shower stall here - box it, plumb in and tile it." If we want a wood burner... put it in.

IMG_8001.JPG


Long story short - we are sailors, we are very handy and we love wood boats. So, what am I missing? My stepson is a diver. We plan to dive and have a look at the hull where she sits. Though I'm not sure what we could determine while she is in the water. I can at least look for rot below the line and determine her draft and hull shape. I know she has a canoe stern but am uncertain of her hull shape and of course condition.

Here are my questions:

1) Based on what you can see here and my description if anyone can tell me more about her design I would be grateful.

2) I believe she could be a capable cruiser - and even perhaps blue water capable. Thoughts?

3) I've been told not to pull her until I'm ready (completely ready) to get busy - the limited research I've done says once she's out - she will dry out and that's worse than rot. Thoughts?

IMG_8017.JPG


I've been told wooden boats require a special kind of madness. I must be mad... because I'm pretty close to pulling the trigger.

Todd
 
Sep 25, 2008
7,336
Alden 50 Sarasota, Florida
Not an owner but have sailed on two different wood hulls. They ride much nicer than comparable glass or steel hulls and the extra maintenance is limited to stuff below the waterline only. They are ‘pulled’ every winter but after a few days, everything expands back like clockwork.
 
Jan 11, 2014
12,700
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
Wooden boats are beautiful to look at and some folks, like @TomY seem to enjoy maintaining them.

There are 2 Youtube channels I've been following about wooden boats, Sampson Boat Company and Acorn to Arabella. The Acorn to Arabella guys have been dismantling a 100 year old wood boat. As they dismantle it they talk about the problems it faced and what caused the problems. You might find it informative. Here's one of the videos, there are several:


Over at Samson Boat Company, Leo is dismantling an old schooner and rebuilding it. Again the early videos show a lot of the damage and he talks about what caused it.


Finally, there is a lot of good information on boats and wooden boats in particular over on OffCenterHarbor.com. It is a pay site, however there are usually a few sample videos available.

Good Luck and I wish you well.
 
Jan 19, 2010
12,553
Hobie 16 & Rhodes 22 Skeeter Charleston
:plus: on reaching out to @TomY

He is the "Been there done that" guy on wooden boats.
 
May 25, 2012
4,338
john alden caravelle 42 sturgeon bay, wis
i see allot of knots in the lumber. that is for house framing, not boats. in fresh water the problem is dry rot, in salt water it's worms.
the boat looks slow. it looks like the builder was not a shipwright.
wood boats are great. they flex in a nice way as they go through the water.
i would find a proper built boat and take that on.
really, there is not enough info to truly asses that vessel.
it looks sorta like a tahiti. they were very slow. like a westsail 32. BUT, they would get you there.
never buy a boat without a proper survey !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

more photos please
 
Sep 25, 2008
7,336
Alden 50 Sarasota, Florida
i see allot of knots in the lumber. that is for house framing, not boats. in fresh water the problem is dry rot, in salt water it's worms.
the boat looks slow. it looks like the builder was not a shipwright.
wood boats are great. they flex in a nice way as they go through the water.
i would find a proper built boat and take that on.
really, there is not enough info to truly asses that vessel.
it looks sorta like a tahiti. they were very slow. like a westsail 32. BUT, they would get you there.
never buy a boat without a proper survey !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

more photos please
Your post reminds me of the saying “some women are built for speed; others for comfort”. Opinions vary which is preferable.
 
  • Like
Likes: jon hansen
Jan 25, 2017
147
Macgregor V222 Kentucky Lake
Thank you Jon - there may be another plan for this boat, maybe not the retirement boat. Maybe a "boatel" or boat B and B. It's another story entirely. But, they are asking (for good reason) $1600. I figured I could salvage the Beta Marine and new mainsail and easily make that back if it was a total wreck.

My partner and I have been looking into Boat B and B ideas. We love getting people started in the sport (especially kids and younger people). It's dying... all my old marina haunts on Kentucky Lake (which is one of the greatest inland sailing lakes this side of the Mississippi!) are now filled with forgotten projects. I had a good laugh with the marina owner as we strolled past the many "abandoned" boats... still paying slip fees. I learned on a Sunfish when I was fourteen and have never looked back. I digress... so, admittedly I saw many of the things you did (in just a photo I might add) but, lacked words.

I just can't see this one go to the burn pile. Long story short... a knock around lake house with sails. More made for comfort at the dock... for a couple and their kids. "Oh and we have a SunFish and Hobie you're welcome to use while you stay." But rustic, and simple.

IMG_7996.JPG
IMG_8013.JPG
IMG_7984.JPG
IMG_7985.JPG
 
Last edited:

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
22,746
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
Very interesting video Dave.

Todd, never owned but sailed and helped maintain several wooden boats over a 5 year span. Got to agree they have character all their own. They require attention and some of it gets in the way of sailing. They sail differently then the production boats discussed here and owned by many of us.
do a little cruising
This is a good place to start. Do you know what you mean by this statement? I would say it needs to be a clear image in your mind when you evaluate any boat, but especially a wooden boat, for purchase.
 
  • Like
Likes: jon hansen
Jan 11, 2014
12,700
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
I'm not sure how that would work as a B & B (Boat and Breakfast?). Insurance might be an issue.

On the other hand, for $1600 to use as a lake camp is a deal that would be hard to beat. The engine alone is worth more than $1600.

Put a few amenities into her and sail around the lake. Practice cruising and staying out a few days. And get the wooden boat bug out of your system, or go all in for nice well maintained Concordia or similar.

Realize that the market for a boat like this is very limited. The price is probably what the prior owner owes in slip fees.
 
May 25, 2012
4,338
john alden caravelle 42 sturgeon bay, wis
boat B&B is a great idea. have a friend making big bags of money with a 50 ft'r that is not seaworthy. it never leaves the dock.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,238
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
I don't think you can turn that into an attractive boat. It would be like polishing a turd. I don't see any appeal. If you want to build a wooden boat, why not really start from scratch with a beautiful design? You'd basically be starting from scratch, but with a boat that is ugly from the get-go. It does have some useful parts that make it worth buying, if you want to build a boat. I don't see any craftmanship in that thing. I'd bet that you could make a far superior effort.

I think that if you want to build a wooden boat (a great dream), then really build a wooden boat! Don't start with a sow's ear. Obtain the plans and materials and get to work! Give that nice red engine a suitable home! You could salvage the figurehead, or not.
 
Jan 25, 2017
147
Macgregor V222 Kentucky Lake
I guess I should have led with that. The BOAT B and B part, that is. I do see her issues. But as I told Jon, maybe I lacked the words to describe. Thanks for the clarification on The Tahiti Jon - I was thinking the West Sail 32 (Wet Snail lol) was very close. O

That would be the plan... make her comfy for overnights, dock nights and slow cruises. We live in Louisville and Air B and B's are really taking off. The thing that interests me the most, is that (and someone please correct me here if I'm wrong) we could apply pretty basic carpentry to this "Folk Type" boat and not get into to much trouble. That and well... it's a $1600 boat. I like the idea of working on her and see if that's what we want to retire on (a wood boat not necessary this wood boat). Or... buy a nice gently used Beneteau Oceanis 31 and call it a day. I think I already know the answer to that... The irony is - I've spent days lecturing Molly (my co-captain) on the reasons we don't want a wood boat... funny how that works. "Newer is better... we don't want to work all the time on a leaky teaky..." And yet here we are.
 
Oct 19, 2017
7,937
O'Day Mariner 19 Littleton, NH
Hi Todd.
I grew up with modern (plywood) wooden boats in the 70s and read and talked a lot about more traditional wooden boats, most of my life. There is a certain routine and mind set around living with them that is simply different from glass boats. There is a lot made about the maintenance of wood over glass. Some true, most is hype or just different concerns.
From your description, I think, if you decide to go ahead with it, consider glassing the hull. Wooden boats do dry out if left too long on the hard, this is not that good for traditional planked construction, but it doesn't happen right away. There's plenty of time to get work done. Not so good for storage. As has been stated, wood swells again and tightens up after time back in the water.
What I like about wood is how easy it is to work with. Most of us have the tools and some experience to affect our own repairs or modifications. Glass is also easy to work with, but it doesn't have the same universal foundation for supplies and knowledge as wood. There is a price to pay for aesthetics. That's what sailing is all about though.

-Will (Dragonfly)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes: Rick D

TomY

Alden Forum Moderator
Jun 22, 2004
2,768
Alden 38' Challenger yawl Rockport Harbor
Wooden boats are beautiful to look at and some folks, like @TomY seem to enjoy maintaining them.
This is a common misconception I've given up trying to correct. :)

I do not own a wooden boat. :) CHRISTMAS is a fiberglass hull and deck boat. It has a lot of wood, but is not a wooden boat (just ask a wooden boat snob :) ).

In 58 seasons, my fiberglass hull hasn't required anything beyond bottom paint, to keep the water on the outside.

THIS is a wooden boat: A hand built hull of thousands of bits of various species of woods, fastenings, caulkings, coatings and maintenance, all relying on each other to keep water on the outside of the hull.

No wooden hull lasts beyond a few - several decades before it requires some serious work (in my observation).
Plank on frame_.jpg



I would own a wooden boat though. However because of how a traditional wooden hull is built I would only buy it after extensive survey and inspection work by several wooden boat experts (I did not get a survey on CHRISTMAS prior to buying).

I do know, what I don't know (that skill took me years to learn): A wooden boat expert can tell what the above hull will require, and when.

Inevitably, a wooden hull will require extensive rebuilding. Without that work, it sinks. There is no way of knowing how much time is left in the OP wooden boat hull before the above point is reached.

I'm convinced, the trick to learn (or pay an expert to determine), with wooden boats is to be sure, you don't own her when that extensive/expensive work is needed.

One thing I do know about wooden boats, they shouldn't leak much at all at the dock after the hulls have swollen up. A small leak at the dock could become a large leak under sail. At any rate, if the boat has been in the water for some time, the leak won't get smaller (I'd fear the opposite).

I wish I could be of more help to the OP. It sounds like a great idea, who knows. Do you feel lucky? :)
 
Sep 26, 2008
690
Hunter 340 0 Wickford, RI
Todd,
I like to think I'm "sane" as you asked. But I have been known to go a little left of center from time to time.
That being said, we love the old wooden boats as well. Pretty much in any reasonable shape, as I can see past the dirt. And it's a safe bet that you'll find us at the Mystic Wooden Boat show each year.
Now that being said, we have a friend that moored his wooden boat behind ours here in Wickford Cove. His name is Tim McElroy and owns the Classic Sailboat Shop. I can tell you he does fantastic restoration work and is willing to help with any questions I ever asked. ( I don't own one myself but would love to).
Contact him at 413-335-6402 or tim.classicsailboatshop@gmail.com
I haven't seen him in a while but if you mention "Wickford Cove Marina...John on s/v Boy on Dolphin, I'm sure he'll be more than happy to help you out. We shared a Hurricane together here in New England a few years back.
Good fortune with the project and the labor of love.
Hope this helps.
 
Jan 25, 2017
147
Macgregor V222 Kentucky Lake
Thanks, Everyone - I guess I should have led with "the plan" first. I understand and even agree with most comments... though I don't think I've ever seen an ugly sailboat. The plan was not to restore a classic... she's no Herreshoff! The idea was "the floating cabin" as explained above... yes a little poking around or motoring when we need to go far. And in the process, learn a bit about woodies... and as I said, if it all goes south, sell the motor and sails. In fact, we might do that anyway. If she truly becomes a BOATEL we would need any of that. Keep the comments coming, but keep the insults to a minimum. I've been around long enough and seen enough great boats to know what she is.