Anytime I'm thristy - depending on conditions
> How is sailing and drinking different than driving and drinking? Ah... the new morality. The difference is that when you are driving a car, a small tweak of the wheel or a moment of lapsed attention is can result in hitting another vehicle which is just a foot or two away in the other lane with a net speed difference of over 100 MPH and people will be killed instantly. But instant reaction time and fine motor control are not at the top of the list of things you need to operate a boat safely. In a sailboat, even without an autopilot, you can (and do) walk away from the helm to work on something and the boat will keep doing what its supposed to do. With autopilot, you might even go below for a few minutes to get something - how long would depend on the level of hazard. For example, you might consider if you are near traffic lanes, on a popular route, if there are the other boats in view, it there is there a lot of driftwood about, all that enters into a calculation of just how quick your reaction time has to be. My understanding is that people cross the oceans and *sleep* while underway on a wind vane. So my view is that all these laws that try to apply land motor vehicle standards to boats get less an less applicable as we get away from smaller high speed boats, and by the time you are looking at a big sailboat, these standards make very little sense. Now I agree that drinking a lot can really impair your judgment in addition to fine motor skills and reaction time, so this is all a question of degree. And part of the judgment being exercised in safe boating would include course, speed, distance from hazards, time of day, weather, oil pressure, wind direction, sail selection as well as the type and amount of drink (and food) consumed. Heck, I hour glassed a spinnaker this summer through a lapse of attention because I had a sandwich in my lap. There were some other factors too, but it was poor judgment on my part, and I don't think anyone would suggest eating should be illegal while piloting. When I go out to pull crab pots in my whaler in the late afternoon I sometimes take a beer with me. It helps me when I have to crack those live crabs over the gunwale. Does this mean that I condone running a go fast boat after a heavy evening at some urban waterfront watering hole? Nope. But that does not mean that I object, or even think it is dangerous if skipper ((but not the foredeck guy) is drinking a few beers between races and a summer twilight series in a J-24. I suspect that many people will see this in black and white and will object to my viewpoint. But I think this is a question of degree, and people need to say so and not get rolled over by blind application of standards that don't apply.