What is the proper response?

Oct 26, 2008
6,247
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
I was with you until that point, but there’s a subtlety there. The leeward boat can come from behind and push up the other boat, but only as high as leeward’s proper course. That proper course could be higher than windward had been sailing and potentially higher than a straight line to the mark in some cases.

But here leeward has the additional restriction that she can’t run windward into the obstruction, even if her proper course would be that high.
Much of this is just common sense. The leeward boat should have no desire to sail above their proper course, especially with the mark approaching. That would only be putting themselves in jeopardy with other boats potentially passing them. The only reason to sail higher than proper course would be to push the windward boat out of spite. So, you don't want to cut your nose off just to spite your face, right? My point about Jackdaw's comment in the past is that you might have to take a beating in one race to ward off somebody who is trying to roll you to windward, but hopefully everybody will learn that you won't be bullied and you won't have to do it again!

With Ray's further explanation, it sounds like he had no choice with the obstructions. Besides that, if he doesn't move out of the way and there is no protest, then I would say that he simply took advantage of room "freely given". There is nothing in the rules against that! Sour grapes after the fact is just that! :biggrin:
 
Sep 29, 2008
1,937
Catalina 310 #185 Quantico
Thank you all for your responses. I actually feel a little bit smarter.