My final fix.... for now. I really want to get an operating bilge pump system and I don't want to spend hours and days to create unique switches that would hopefully be more reliable.
So for now, or until the next failure, I have opted to install two Water Witch 101 12V switches. A low mounted one will control my pump, and a higher one will just activate an audio alarm.
I am going to mount these switches in a manner that provides easy access and replacement, just in case. I'll post a picture of my completed project.