What hunter to take?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
Me and a couple of friends want to take a hunter out to marthas vineyard from Boston harbor. What size would sit 8 comfortably and be ocean worthy?
 
Sep 25, 2008
7,470
Alden 50 Sarasota, Florida
The cockpit size should be self-evident. The crew is the limiting factor, not the boat. This is one of those questions that always makes me expect an upcoming distress call to the CG.
 
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
Don S/V ILLusion said:
The cockpit size should be self-evident. The crew is the limiting factor, not the boat. This is one of those questions that always makes me expect an upcoming distress call to the CG.
We will have a 3 man crew including me. The skipper will be either my dad or my friend's dad.
 
Oct 29, 2010
136
Hunter 36 Pensacola
Depends on how agile your passengers are. If they are able to sit on the side of the boat then it leaves more for the cockpit. If all 8 must be in the cockpit then I would go big. We have a 36 and it gets cramped with 8 but it can be done.
 
Dec 19, 2006
5,832
Hunter 36 Punta Gorda
Big

I would go at least 36 but 38 and 41 would be better,I have a 07 H-36 and 6 no problem on a long trip and day sailing 8 is doable also.
I sailed my 36 from Montauk,NY to Florida all offshore and plenty room for the 4 crew we had and the 36 has OK room for 8 in cockpit but 8 sleeping down below or eating will be tight.
How long of a trip are you planning and will you be stopping in marina's along the way, 8 will need big water tank if showing on boat so if you can I would get a 41.
If wanting to save $$$$$ 36 is a good size boat to make the trip it just depends on how freindly every one is,my 07 36 has lots of storage and very big cockpit storage compartant on port side cockpit table is nice size,really depends how much time on water and in a anchorage or marina,36 will hold 8 and a good offshore boat too and easy to handle especially if getting In-mast.
What year boats are you looking at.
Nick
 
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
seadaddler said:
I would go at least 36 but 38 and 41 would be better,I have a 07 H-36 and 6 no problem on a long trip and day sailing 8 is doable also.
I sailed my 36 from Montauk,NY to Florida all offshore and plenty room for the 4 crew we had and the 36 has OK room for 8 in cockpit but 8 sleeping down below or eating will be tight.
How long of a trip are you planning and will you be stopping in marina's along the way, 8 will need big water tank if showing on boat so if you can I would get a 41.
If wanting to save $$$$$ 36 is a good size boat to make the trip it just depends on how freindly every one is,my 07 36 has lots of storage and very big cockpit storage compartant on port side cockpit table is nice size,really depends how much time on water and in a anchorage or marina,36 will hold 8 and a good offshore boat too and easy to handle especially if getting In-mast.
What year boats are you looking at.
Nick
Thanks for the reply.
Well I'm 14 and have started sailing 23 foot sonars. My two friends who are both incredible sailers would be the crew. Now my friends mom who is thought of sailing to Marthas vineyard is coming and as a skipper my dad. That's 5 people. Also what about a water tank? The longest I've sailed is a mile so I'm not sure how thirsty I'll be.
 
Jun 2, 2004
5,802
Hunter 37-cutter, '79 41 23' 30"N 82 33' 20"W--------Huron, OH
I have sailed on the H38, the H44, and the H46. None of those boats would seat eight comfortably in the cockpit. We had six on the H46 and that was very comfortable. It was also a three cabin boat which was great for three couples. The water tanks are adequate but most people put a couple of cases of bottled water on the boat.
 
Dec 19, 2006
5,832
Hunter 36 Punta Gorda
Bottle Water

Like Ed said everyone would bring a few cases of bottle wter,tank water is used for washing dishes and crew washing.
How long are you planning to stay out on the boat and what is choices do you have from a charter company.
Bigger would be better for family trip with more cabins and maybe 2 heads,my wife and I fine my H-36 plenty room and when I have gone cruising with all guy crew we need less room for sure.
But your family vacation would do better with bigger,you will not always be in the cockpit sailing along and will need room for cooking breakfast,lunch and dinner down below and sleeping for 8 in my H-36 won't work for sure.
Went on a charter with 6 and captain and cook on a 46 cat and now that was a real roomy boat and we all had our own room and head and plenty of room in cockpit and in cabin for sure.
Nick
 
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
seadaddler said:
Like Ed said everyone would bring a few cases of bottle wter,tank water is used for washing dishes and crew washing.
How long are you planning to stay out on the boat and what is choices do you have from a charter company.
Bigger would be better for family trip with more cabins and maybe 2 heads,my wife and I fine my H-36 plenty room and when I have gone cruising with all guy crew we need less room for sure.
But your family vacation would do better with bigger,you will not always be in the cockpit sailing along and will need room for cooking breakfast,lunch and dinner down below and sleeping for 8 in my H-36 won't work for sure.
Went on a charter with 6 and captain and cook on a 46 cat and now that was a real roomy boat and we all had our own room and head and plenty of room in cockpit and in cabin for sure.
Nick
Well it's like a 6 hour journey with good wind. I am not sure what a charter company is... as you can see I am a newbie so I need all the advice I can get. Other than that. Do hunters keel alot on beam reaches?
 
Jun 2, 2004
5,802
Hunter 37-cutter, '79 41 23' 30"N 82 33' 20"W--------Huron, OH
Here is one Boston charter company as an example: http://www.bostonsailingcenter.com/charters/bostoncharters.asp . Do you have a qualified skipper among your family and friends? If not then you will have to charter the boat with a captain. Either way a big boat is pricey. Not sure about 2011 but a captain used to get at least $150. per day. Some companies will not permit "bareboat" charters. This is where you supply your own qualified captain. You will have to Google and then call the companies. In the link above I see no mention of "bareboat".
 
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
Ed Schenck said:
Here is one Boston charter company as an example: http://www.bostonsailingcenter.com/charters/bostoncharters.asp . Do you have a qualified skipper among your family and friends? If not then you will have to charter the boat with a captain. Either way a big boat is pricey. Not sure about 2011 but a captain used to get at least $150. per day. Some companies will not permit "bareboat" charters. This is where you supply your own qualified captain. You will have to Google and then call the companies. In the link above I see no mention of "bareboat".
Well if someone in my family wanted to become a qualified skipper, how long would it take to get the qualified? I'm not so sure that I can take out a sonar 23 all the way to marthas vineyard.
 
Jun 2, 2004
5,802
Hunter 37-cutter, '79 41 23' 30"N 82 33' 20"W--------Huron, OH
Aug 6, 2011
12
Sonar Sonar 23 CBI
Thanks for the helpful links. For now I think I'll stick to sailing on the charles but who knows maybe next year I can go to the harbor.
 
Apr 27, 2010
1,279
Hunter 23 Lake Wallenpaupack
At minimum, if you or your father don't already have the experience, take a course from the Power Squadron or Coast Guard Auxiliary on coastal navigation. If you don't know how to navigate, read charts, etc. you don't want to try to sail to the Vineyard in anything. I would also not do it without some solid experience offshore, with an instructor, captain, etc. A daysailer on the Charles won't give you that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.