Well, I finally did it - I ripped out my icebox. Just getting it out took two 3-day weekends. I'm glad I made the decision to replace it though. For any of you that wonder where the water goes that drains out the bottom, mine went into the insulation under the box. It was soaked so bad that a piece of 1/2 in plywood that was between the fiberglass and the insulation was just mush. That part of the insulation (the bottom of the box) basically had zero insulating qualities. It did have a small hose that was routed to the bilge, but it had come loose from the fitting on the bottom of the box and left everything drain into the insulation. Also, though in some places there was up to 8 or 10 inches of insulation, the back wall of the box (the bulkhead between the box and the cockpit/engine compartment) had only about one inch.I'll take pictures of the rebuild and post later. I'm actually putting in a whole new galley, so may take a while.