Troubleshooting mainsail trim

Jul 31, 2023
15
Starwind 19 Yarmouth, ME
Actually, one more question for folks. I have not seen a clew/foot arrangement like the one on the new-to-me sail. It has what appears to be a foot rope running the length of the foot, but it has a separate slug connected to the clew itself (which I have only seen on open-footed sails). Am I right in interpreting is likely still a closed-footed sail? Photo attached.
 

Attachments

May 17, 2004
5,673
Beneteau Oceanis 37 Havre de Grace
Actually, one more question for folks. I have not seen a clew/foot arrangement like the one on the new-to-me sail. It has what appears to be a foot rope running the length of the foot, but it has a separate slug connected to the clew itself (which I have only seen on open-footed sails). Am I right in interpreting is likely still a closed-footed sail? Photo attached.
Yes, based on where that bolt rope is I think so. My guess is the slug is there to help keep the corner load on the clew ring and not the back end of the bolt rope.
 
Jul 31, 2023
15
Starwind 19 Yarmouth, ME
Yes, it does. The old sail had a foot rope. The presence of the slug just confused me, but the explanation that it is there to manage loads on the foot rope makes sense to me. Thanks!
 

Joe

.
Jun 1, 2004
8,193
Catalina 27 Mission Bay, San Diego
Yes, it does. The old sail had a foot rope. The presence of the slug just confused me, but the explanation that it is there to manage loads on the foot rope makes sense to me. Thanks!
My old North Sails attached foot main, that came with the boat when I acquired it, had both a bolt rope and a robust slider lashed to the clew. It was a pretty high quality sail (as most North Sails products are) with three reefs, leather reinforced corner patches, draft stripes, and believe it or not, a "shelf foot".... which is an additional lightweight panel of cloth sewn in along the sail's foot. The cloth panel expands (unfolds) when the outhaul is released, allowing the sail's "belly" to expand dramatically... just as it does on a loose foot mainsail. When the outhaul is trimmed to depower the sail, the panel folds into the foot... literally disappearing as the sail flattens.

The purpose of mentioning the shelf foot is this: Most of the "load" on the mainsail.... attached foot or loose foot... is at the Corners.! That's why reinforcing the corners is a common design feature. When you look at radial design sails.... the seams radiate from the corners. You'll see lighter cloth panels in the middle areas between the corners.....and heavier stronger cloth from the corners toward the center of the sail... So... adding a lightweight panel of cloth along the base of an attached foot sail, a shelf, would support the idea that the corners are doing most of the work. It would also make sense that adding a slug to the clew's connection to the boom isn't to help the foot' bolt rope, but it is there because the clew is where the load is and that's where the help is needed.
 
Jan 1, 2006
7,574
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
So, I wonder if it would be better to sail with the foot rope in or out of the groove? I think your out haul adjustments will be easier without.