My experiences: Lots of screws = lots of possible leaks. If screw holes are countersunk for bevelled screws, the ring is weakened and splits readily if screws are slightly overtightened. I glued my new ones on with Lifecalk - or maybe it was Lifeseal (It was the one containing silicone) - and they seem to be holding. Needed to clamp them with large C-clamps.
Best tool for cutting old ones off is a really thin, sharpened 1"scraper or a Fein multi-tool with scraper blade. The chances are some rings are going to break anyway as they become very brittle with UV. I think painting them should improve longevity.