Different Horses for Different Courses
J, it really depends on your personality.I studied a beginner's book, Bill Bond's The Handbook of Sailing, and understood 90% of what I read (I'm still trying to get my head around the basic meteoroloy). It all made sense to me. I remember sitting on the couch, book in one hand, the other extended to grasp an imaginary tiller, pushing it away, and moving to to another cushion on the couch during virtual "tacks," and such.When I'd read the book several times, and sailing the couch became passé, I bought a 14' sailing dinghy and towed it down to the marina, and taught myself in a relatively protected bay. Sure, I tipped the thing over a few times (slow-moving ballast w/ bad knees, and one surprise gybe/broach), but it was always instructive. I considered it part of the process, and always came home happy (and sometimes wet).After a only a couple of outings, I had the basics down and began honing skills. Before long I made it out the marina channel and along the public beach. "Open water" at last!I took a class my second summer, just to see If I was missing anything, and it only confirmed that I'd taught myself well. Shortly thereafter I bought my first keelboat, a 22-ft swing-keel Catalina 22. I'm now owner of a 10,000 lb. C30, and regularly cross the San Pedro Channel for weekends @ Catalina Island. Anchoring still causes me pause, but it's more magic than science, anyway. ; )I recommend classes to people in general, but if you're my type (studiously read, re-read, then go and do; like to take on the challenges and make your mistakes by yourself), there's no reason you can't teach yourself. I found it very satisfying. If you're safety-conscious, limit yourself to gentle weather for a while, know how to right a capsized dinghy and get underway again, and can wave cheerfully at those who laugh at you, what's the worst that can happen except some public embarrassment?JeffP.S.— I'd choose something bigger than an eight foot sabot, but nothing larger than a fourteen foot or so daysailer, like a Lido, which can offer very good performance. If you're teaching yourself, nineteen feet might be a bit much for your student to handle.