To plumb, or not to plumb?

Status
Not open for further replies.
May 20, 2007
50
Macgregor 26X Maryland
I've got a Dometic 975MSD in my MacGregor 26X, which I bought to replace the freeze-damaged Sani-Pottie that came with the boat. (Ugh. But could have been worse.) The marina where I was keeping it had nothing against dumping them in their toilets - but, since I was only day-sailing (and used the marina head those few times I stayed overnight), I never needed to use the thing.

Now I've moved to another marina in a location with better sailing - and they do prohibit dumping porta-potties in their toilets. It's a "Maryland Clean Marina," so they do have a pump-out ... but I've never used it; in fact, I haven't used the potty. But now I plan on doing more multi-day trips, anchoring out and "living aboard"....

Will it work for me to "pump out" the potty through its flush-valve, with the bottom tank (holding tank) on the dock? Or had I really better plumb it to a deck connection? (I have the potty-side hardware; will have to buy hoses, a deck connection and a vent.)

Also, if I do the plumbing, how much of a problem (and how gross) would it be to "un-plumb" it if I need to do so? I plan to "trailer-cruise" some during the coming months, probably spending a couple of weeks away at a time. There may be times & places where I wouldn't be able to pump out but I could dump out ...
 
Dec 2, 1997
8,954
- - LIttle Rock
Plumb

Plumb it for pumpout. The tank CAN be pumped out sitting on the dock...but remember that a full 5 gal tank weighs more than 40 lbs, which would be a major PITA to pull out and carry off the boat every time. Removing the tank to take it ashore when you have no other choice isn't that big a deal...the fittings are all on the top, so it's not all that gross...and fairly easy to do, especially if you can find some 1.5" quick connect fittings that would eliminate the need to remove any hoses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.