What!!!
disclaimer- this is coming from a novice saior and experienced car mehanic and racer.Synthetic oil is INCREDIBLE and I would not trust an expensive motor to anything else. Yes, you are 100% correct about it dissolving sludge, and in an engine with more than roughly 2000 hours the seal rubber tends to get "replaced" by sludge- it actually forms a pretty good seal for moving parts. So now your rear main seal rubber has worn away .030 from the shaft, and that gap bridged by sludge. Synthetic goes in, and BAM now you have a gaping oil leak. So for an old motor with many hours on it, don't change. However, for any motor in relatively "new" condition, I can't understand why you wouldnt run synthetic. The lubricated parts virtually do not wear- even in an oval-track stock car where the oil pump sucks air around the corners. Cold starts, oil flow problems caused by sludged-up passages, bearing knock, splash-lubricated places (such as cylinder walls and piston pins), valve guides, is all improved by the synthetic oil, plus it doesn't eat seal rubber. If your engine is newish, do it. It will still be newish a long time from now. (change filters 2x as often as the oil itself is my personal pattern)If your engine is old, don't. When it finally does come time for the rebuild, replace everything and then switch.