Support at haul out

Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Rob Johnson

I recently hauled my 430 using a marine rail system at the local marina. The keel rests on a wooden pad and steel arms reach in to grab the bow and stern to steady the boat during the haul out. I had some concerns as the boat came out of the water. The 430’s keel has a rounded bulb and all the weight of the boat was resting on the rear three fins. The balance of the boat was somewhat precarious rocking on the rear keel as the center of gravity is aft of the keel. I called Hunter and was told that they do not recommend more that 50% weight on the keel and that any haul should be done by placing the boat in its original shipping cradle. His concern was the weight of the boat on the hull at the keel joint might lead to structural failure. I was very glad to get the boat back into the water with no damage (??) While I will not use this system again, it seems that the standard jack supports used by all the yards do no more than steady a boat while the bulk of the weight rests on the keel. It also made me very concerned about finding the bottom on an outgoing tide. Shouldn’t a sail boat be designed to be able to support its weight on the keel? I don’t know who I talked to at Hunter or what his design knowledge level is but I did appreciate the prompt return call and the information he provided.
 

Attachments

F

Frank Walker

Are we sailing around in eggs.

Rob, sounds like you were talking to a lawyer at Hunter rather than someone that ought to know better. Any sailboat that can not support the complete hull weight on the keel in a yard situation is not fit to put to sea in. I think Hunter is just playing CYA or CTA in this situation.
 
B

Bob belvin

Same thing with my 33.5

The owner and travel lift operator in the yard where I had my boat hauled last year noticed the stern sag as he lowered my boat onto the keel before placing the side jacks. He added 4 more jacks on the stern to support it. I have the same fear as you about a hard grounding and wonder if some internal bracing could be added.
 
May 7, 2004
119
Hunter 33.5 Saint Louis
9 stands on 33.5

Our harbor master claims all boats on stands sit on their keels. The stands merely keep them from falling over. Is this true? Our 33.5 uses 9 stands. We left our mast up while on stands. Does anyone else? Jeff
 
Status
Not open for further replies.