Fluxgate Facing??
on my new Raymarine S-1 autopilot shows the fluxgate compass mounted so it is "facing forward". That is, it's screwed to the foreward side of an aft bulkhead or mounting. Could it be that you've mounted yours facing aft?
I second this prognosis!
You say you got a new control head and it is off by 180 degrees...
Well, when I installed my brand new ST4000+ MKII a couple years back I was faced with the dilema of finding the right place to install it. It turned out to be just below the companionway ladder right at the cabin sole but I was concerned someones heel would land on it so I put it in behind facing aft. I knew this was going to be a problem because I tested it while taping it in place facing forward and aft. I took my chances and mounted it facing aft, then went out and did my sea trials and swung the compass while correcting for 180 degrees. Yes, it worked, my compass now behaves as if it was facing forward.
Your previous owner likely did the same thing as me and when you got a new control head you did not do the sea trial and correct for the 180 degrees of an aft facing fluxgate. New control head needs to be calibrated to the boat. Check to see which way the compass is facing. From anothers viewpoint here, it never occurred to me to switch the wires around to the opposite connection, I wonder if that would have worked for me, too late now, what's done is done and it works like a charm.:dance: