Smelly Hotwater

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nov 29, 2006
12
- - mattapoisett,ma.
I have noticed this summer that when I run the hot water in my sink or head that it has a very foul odor. The cold water side has no odor at all. I have refilled the fresh water tanks 3 times this season and I still have the hot water smell. The boat is a 1988 Catalina 30. I have never had this problem before. Do the hot water tanks deteriorate or could it be something in the heat exchanger?
Perplexed.
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,047
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
The trick: get used to using the HOT water faucet whenever you turn on the water, especially when there is no hot water available (either at the dock or none from motoring). This keeps the water moving through the heater. This topic keeps coming up every once in a while.
 
Nov 29, 2006
12
- - mattapoisett,ma.
Stu,
Thanks for the info. As this has not happened before and I have owned the boat for 4 years, is there an explanation as to why it happens all of a sudden?
Thanks.
 
Jun 1, 2004
121
Catalina 22 PA
I'm not familiar with how water heaters work on boats, as I sail on a C22, but I assume they are electric. If so, I've read that sometimes the heating element goes bad and can cause a rotten egg type smell in the water. Maybe you could talk with the manufacturer.
 
Aug 3, 2009
109
Catalina 30 great neck, ny
I'm not familiar with how water heaters work on boats, as I sail on a C22, but I assume they are electric. If so, I've read that sometimes the heating element goes bad and can cause a rotten egg type smell in the water. Maybe you could talk with the manufacturer.
I have experienced the same thing with my hot water heater that is hooked only to the cooling line. The odor may be coming from heating the water line that somehow releases sulfur. There may be some product that is added to the water tanks that treats this condition.
 
Jul 1, 2004
398
Catalina 30 Atlanta GA
What your smelling is H2S = Hydrogen Sulfide (gas) or what folks refer to as "rotten egg smell". By not using the hot water, sulfide bacteria is released leaving it stagnant in the tank which furthers bacterial buildup. Heat will not kill these suckers! You must run your hot water on occasion to replenish the tank, clear out the bacteria and the lines. I always add a tablespoon or two of clorox/bleach when I fill up my tanks despite the marina's potable supply source coming from municipal supplies and already dissinfected. I do this because most boatowners on my dock seldom are on their vessels and as such the water does not get much flushing.

Bob
'88 Mark II
Georgia
 
Jan 6, 2010
1,520
Hey Pick53,
Bob nailed your problem.
I have a routine I've used for 10 years now and never have problems with odor. I live in Florida so my water really warms up in my tanks. Years ago I used bleach what was popular then.

I decided use something different because I hate the smell of bleach, and also bleach being acidic, will etch the hose I.D. and create gas. When first turning on water there will almost always be a slight odor as this is the gas formed in your hose. This should only last a few seconds and not strong.

I use...........are you ready? Simple POOL CHLORINE (liquid, not granule as this leaves sediment in your tank). It has aromatics and will not eat your hoses or create alot of gas.
There are different types, but all brands I've used over the years have all worked fine.
Also as Bob mentioned, run your water (when not heated) thru the hot side faucet frequently. It will keep your HW tank flushed.

I have 2 water tanks, an 18 & 23 gal tank. w/6gal. HW tank.
Start by shocking your system with 1 OZ. in each tank & completely fill system. Heat up your HW tank and walk away for a couple hours.

Do a complete flush (HW tank turned off) and drain it completely down. Add 1/4 OZ per tank. Do this and your water will smell as good as your back yard pool with no odors. I have had my water sit for sometimes 2-3 months, with no foul odors. You will find with some trial & error the correct amount for you.

Let me know if you try this & it works pal......

CR
 
Nov 29, 2006
12
- - mattapoisett,ma.
To all,
Now it all makes sense. There has been a record breaking heat wave in New England so far this summer which would explain why I have not had this problwm in the past. Capn'Ron you said you live in Florida and this is a common problem down there with the heat.
I will treat my tanks per your recommendation.
Thanks again.
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,047
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Guys, I beg to differ. If you need to clean your water systems, use Peggie's tried and true method. Do a search on "recommissioning" using Peggie Hall as author, right here on this board.

Otherwise, simply do what I suggested earlier.

Simple.
 
Jul 1, 2004
398
Catalina 30 Atlanta GA
Let me add a bit more on the subject.........
Water heaters are a source of hydrogen sulfide. Sulfur reducing bacteria live in oxygen deficient environments such as water heaters. Sulfates can buildup on the heating rods inside the water tanks, so flushing the system is important. Heat forces the gas into the air, so thats what you get when you immediately turn on your hot water faucet; hydrogen sulfide gas or the smell of rotten eggs. At its worst, a black slim can form and clog lines, plumbing and tanks if left alone for a long time. The preferred method of sulfur treatment is ozone. Seeing that H2S has a chlorine demand, it takes a bit of chlorine/bleach to shock the bacteria. Using filters is okay for home use when continuous line flushing is going on (dishwashers, washing machines, bathing, etc), but on vessels where we might get on the water for a weekend or two a month, opening the hot water tap and clearing the line might be required. I use only an in-line screen filter for particulate trapping. If you travel the back roads of southern towns you'll often see "cascading aerators". These are small buildings with a screened upper portion, whereby the groundwater is pumped up and allowed to splash on a series of boards to release the H2S to the air. After that, gas chlorination is used to dissenfect the potable supply. I know, I used to inspect them! The bottom line here is stay on top of the condition knowing that a stagnant hot water heater can cause a problem. Which ever way you choose to flush, treat, release or reduce the H2S problem is up to you.

Good luck

Bob
"88 Mark II
Georgia
 
Status
Not open for further replies.