Sizing a prop

Status
Not open for further replies.
Feb 3, 2009
292
Knysna 550 SE Knysna, South Africa
I'm in La Paz, Mexico trying to get my boat ready to head to El Salvador. I just installed my newly refurbished MaxProp and then had a survey done before splashing the boat. Based upon the survey, it was suggested that I replace the cutlass bearing because it was getting worn and there were facilities to do it here, whereas there wouldn't be many as we headed south.

So, I disassembled the prop and asked the yard to to pull the part of it which is slides onto the tapered shaft. I was up above disconnecting the shaft from the transmission flange and PSS seal, so I never saw it come off.

After a battle to get the shaft out, we replace the cutlass bearing, but when I went to reassemble the prop, the part that the yard had pulled was nowhere to be found. The mechanic swears that he wrapped it in some paper towels and placed it next to the other pieces which were sitting on our wing keel. Four hours of searching didn't turn up anything, so I called PYI to see if it was possible to get a new part flown in. They stated that they needed the entire prop back to fit one, and that isn't possible within our time frame.

Thus I think that the only option is to install a fixed 2 blade prop. The MaxProp is a 3 blade 20" with an 18 degree pitch. According to the boat's manual, it comes standard with a 2 blade 20"x13 prop. How do these numbers compare (i.e. 18 degree pitch vs 13" slip).

FYI, the boat is a 15 ton Freedom 40/40 (35' LWL) with a Yanmar 3JH2-TBE (turbo) 45 HP with a sweet spot for torque and fuel economy at about 2800 RPM.

-- Geoff
 

CalebD

.
Jun 27, 2006
1,479
Tartan 27' 1967 Nyack, NY
So the yard workers "lost" your MaxProp? You have been had my friend. Sorry to hear about this.

Switching from a 3 blade to 2 blade prop is going to effect everything about motoring. For one thing, going in reverse is going to be a lot more difficult. Your sweet spot for cruising will likely be different as well.

The 18 prop is steeper than your 13 prop. The pitch of the 18 will go through 18" on one rotation but the 13 will only go through 13". A good prop shop can adjust the pitch of your new prop should you feel it necessary.
 
Feb 3, 2009
292
Knysna 550 SE Knysna, South Africa
No, they lost 1 part of it. I just discovered a photo that shows the part laying on the ground while they were moving stands on my boat to get to a boat behind mine.

I understand the issues associated with the 2 blade prop. Note that the MaxProp is specified in degrees vs inches on the fixed blade prop.
 
Oct 17, 2011
2,809
Ericson 29 Southport..
Just my opinion, but if the yard lost my expensive piece, and a word of prayer didn't rectify the situation, next step would be a laying on of hands.
 

Rick D

.
Jun 14, 2008
7,204
Hunter Legend 40.5 Shoreline Marina Long Beach CA
You know, this may not be helpful, but you just know that part is around. I'd offer a $100 reward with a one week expiration. What's to lose?

I have a two blade off my 40.5 Hunter, but I'd be surprised if we were lucky enough that it would work (altho the power and boat size are close). If it would, I could ship it to you expedited, but it would cost. PM me if interested. It would be a loan for as long as needed.
 
Sep 15, 2009
6,244
S2 9.2a Fairhope Al
No, they lost 1 part of it. I just discovered a photo that shows the part laying on the ground while they were moving stands on my boat to get to a boat behind mine.

quote]

sounds to me like its time for them to go digging in the dirt and sift the dirt till they find the part..... if you have a pic of it sitting there then they need to get going on finding it......

( the difference between ignorance and apathy ........the answer........i don't know and further more i don't give a damn....... )

regards

woody
 
Sep 25, 2008
1,096
CS 30 Toronto
MaxProp manual

20" at 18deg = 12.1 pitch. So 13 is about right for 2 blades. See picture.
It came from Maxprop manual.
 

Attachments

Sep 25, 2008
1,096
CS 30 Toronto
For 3 blades, go to web site

If you go to Maxprop site you can download a 3 blades manual. As I recall the chart is the same.

You do need to send it back to be fitted. They have to match the parts together in order to be sure they fit smoothly.

Sorry about your lost. It's a pain. The yard should pay for it and loan you a temp prop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.