Hi Ryan, do you want to refinish...
your sole? As long as the material has not de-laminated I would refinish the original. Much easier than replacing, IMHO. Our sole material is the traditional teak holly marine grade plywood...good stuff. It still looks good. At the point I decide to refinish I intend to remove each section, clean with a lacquer solvent, fill any places with a color matching putty, lightly sand the old finish then use a clear gloss spray can lacquer from HD. Easy to work with, durable and restores the sole to original sheen.Terry