Shallow Water

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jim

Just sold my Potter 19 because of the 37 inch draw. Now exploring a swing keel model like the 192 to 222. I sail in shallow area in 2 1/2 to 3 feet of water in spots. How much do you sacrifice in stability by having the board partially retracted so that it only draws 2 1/2 feet? Any help would be greatly appreciated.
 
B

Bayard Gross

You lose upwind ability

As I have found on my C-22, when you retract the keel you don't realy lose stability as much as the ability to sail straight into the wind. You end upgoing sideways as much as forward especially if the wind has any strength. This why keels are made deep.
 
R

Rod Johnson,

The O'Days were Keel/Centerboards

The O'Days were not swing-keel boats, they had Keel/Centerboards, so although they do lose a bit of windward pointing ability with the centerboard up, they will still sail that way. The board is only lightly ballasted, so stability is unaffected by board position. The board serves more to aid manuevering and balance the helm. Raising the board partway moves the center of resistance to sideways slip aft, and increases "lee helm" (boat is more prone to turn the bow away from wind), lowering the board increases "weather helm" (boat is more prone to turn the bow into the wind). Several O'Day owners (various models, 20, 22, 222, 23, 25, 26) report that they sail often with the board partway or fully up and say the boat still sails, but will tend to slip sideways more than if the board were down. On the section of this web-site that has manuals and brochures, there is a scan of a 1980 O'Day 22,23,25 brochure. It contains a good sales pitch for the Keel/Centerboard design and how it is better than the Retractable-Keel designs of O'Day's competition.
 
J

John

Shallow Water Sailing

Jim, I too sail the same area off Surf City NJ in my 1982 O'day 22. this boat has a shoal draft keel/centerboard. Most of the time I sail with the board all the way up. Yes, you might lose some ability to point but he boat sill sails very well. I am able to sail just about anywhere do to the 15" draft of the keel. If I want more control I put 1/2 board down and I can still sail alot of places that keel boats cannot go. SO if you're thinking about a 22, make sure theat .it is a shoal draft/centerboard model, which was only made for about 4 years. all of the other 22's & all of the 222's have the fixed keel which I think may draw approx 2 feet. Good luck, hope to see you on the bay in Surf City John (X-T-Sea)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.