While I also strive to retard the rate of bank account depletion, I would side with Warren on this one. Getting a full season on a zinc would be pretty darn good for many folks. Even if your zincs still have some meat left, will they protect for another full season? You didn't mention where the zincs are mounted. If a shaft or prop zinc, as they deplete, the zinc metal around the clamp through-holes for the bolts gets thinner and the zinc metal brittle. One day the zinc looks ok, the next day it's fallen off and gone. The cost of a diver to replace one zinc probably would equal several seasons of new zincs -- that's assuming you are in a location where the boat is pulled every winter and you can replace the zincs yourself on the hard?