Welcome aboard, Bob!
If the water is dirty, it's backflow from the head discharge. If it's clean, it's flush water from the intake. Whichever it is, you won't cure it by taking the pump apart or rebuilding it...'cuz if it's flush water, the part that's leaking isn't in the rebuild kit...if it's backflow, a new joker valve will only slow it down. Is water rising in the bowl when boat sits? Or only when you're underway or shortly after you come in from sailing? Even if a rebuild kit would cure the problem, I would not spend $50 for a rebuild kit for a toilet that's usually on sale somewhere for $99. The Raritan PH II (or PHC, which is the same pump on a compact base to fit in a tighter space) will give you at least 20 years of reliable trouble-free service with minimal maintenance--keep it well lubricated, rebuild every 5-6 years. And it will easily "swallow" flushes that choke a Jabsco. As for West Marine, their prices have gotten ridiculous! Their prices on almost everything is 10-50% higher than factory LIST price now...I was stunned to see that their price for a 22 oz bottle of Raritan K.O. is a whopping $17.95...LIST price is only $11.90. So before you buy anything there, shop around!Meanwhile, I also suggest you do two things: 1. check out the link below to learn how marine toilets work and how to maintain your whole system. 2. There has been a lot of discussion here about water rising in the bowl, especially in the last week or two...so read the previous threads in the "Head Mistress" forum, and also search the archives for posts about toilets in other forums (as you can see from this threads, they show up in all of 'em, which definitely keeps ME hopping!)...you should find quite a bit about marine toilet and holding tank issues if you search all forums by poster using my name as your keyword.