Reducing the smell
- Thread starter EdWard3
- Start date
I think it is likely a one way valve allowing the head to suck air apposed to sewage in the event of a head pump malfunction. may also prevent head damage when being pumped out. obviously it should not vent out into the cabin.
Just a guess I do not know for certain.
Just a guess I do not know for certain.
It is probably the raw water supply line to the head. As you noted that is the only place you would need one.
You don't need one on the head to holding tank line unless the holding tank full level is above the head empty level.
You don't need one on the head to holding tank line unless the holding tank full level is above the head empty level.
I have a vented loop in the manual pump out line that goes from the tank thru the manual pump, to the underwater thru-hull.. Is that the line that is vented? If it is in the head discharge, and that discharge is not connected to a thru-hull, then it is not needed.
chlorinated water
change your water supply for the head to your drinking water tanks and the smell will go away. Yes you will use more water, but no smell.
I have done this on my 37c and fixed my small problem.
change your water supply for the head to your drinking water tanks and the smell will go away. Yes you will use more water, but no smell.
I have done this on my 37c and fixed my small problem.
A siphon break in the head to holding tank discharge line?
A siphon break in the head intake (the the line between in the sea water through hull to the head) needs to be looped high with a siphon break.
Not so the head discharge to holding tank line. In fact, no sanitary line on the discharge side needs a siphon break. If there is a holding tank in the mix a siphon threat via a holding tank is impossible because the holding tank is already vented thus no siphon threat is possible.
In short, no sanitary discharge line can be exposed to the boat interior.
Your arrangement is providing unpleasant consequences. Remove this device pronto. But -- double check that your holding tank to atmosphere vent line is open - no kinks, no vent hose failures either.
Charles
A siphon break in the head intake (the the line between in the sea water through hull to the head) needs to be looped high with a siphon break.
Not so the head discharge to holding tank line. In fact, no sanitary line on the discharge side needs a siphon break. If there is a holding tank in the mix a siphon threat via a holding tank is impossible because the holding tank is already vented thus no siphon threat is possible.
In short, no sanitary discharge line can be exposed to the boat interior.
Your arrangement is providing unpleasant consequences. Remove this device pronto. But -- double check that your holding tank to atmosphere vent line is open - no kinks, no vent hose failures either.
Charles
Edward.. check out this article which (almost) shows correct head plumbing:
http://www.westmarine.com/WestAdvisor/Selecting-a-Sanitation-System
You cannot have a siphon break on the intake to the head (as is erroneously shown in the last diagram in the article) because that would not let the pump take suction water in. The break, if ya need one, goes between the head pump and the toilet bowl, on the pump discharge. My 34 came from Hunter with plumbing very similar to the second-to-last picture in the article except I do not have valve #8 and so there is a siphon break in the line between #9 and #10. That break is necessary because without #8 valve, seawater could back up into the holding tank when heeled (assuming the discharge thru-hulll is open). If the siphon break valve is clean and working correctly, it will not allow odor into the boat. Many of the siphon break valves can be disassembled for cleaning or replacement.
http://www.westmarine.com/WestAdvisor/Selecting-a-Sanitation-System
You cannot have a siphon break on the intake to the head (as is erroneously shown in the last diagram in the article) because that would not let the pump take suction water in. The break, if ya need one, goes between the head pump and the toilet bowl, on the pump discharge. My 34 came from Hunter with plumbing very similar to the second-to-last picture in the article except I do not have valve #8 and so there is a siphon break in the line between #9 and #10. That break is necessary because without #8 valve, seawater could back up into the holding tank when heeled (assuming the discharge thru-hulll is open). If the siphon break valve is clean and working correctly, it will not allow odor into the boat. Many of the siphon break valves can be disassembled for cleaning or replacement.
A failed anti-siphon in the discharge (failed such that it is open) remains a prime suspect. All things considered - it is also possible the odor is coming from a failed holding tank vent line or a failed head to tank line joint - all of which are exposed to the boat interior.
On the inlet side - Kloudie is right. Apologies for my lack of clarity -- do not put a siphon break in the intake to head-pump line. Rather - see to it you have one in the pump to bowl line so as to avoid a potential siphon threat.
As to that last West diagram - you achieve nothing with a siphon break in the seawater discharge line unless your wye valve can bypass the holding tank- thus running waste from the head direct to seawater. In fact, if you plumbed things the way the last West diagram shows it would be impossible to discharge waste from the tank directly to seawater at all unless you had dedicated discharge pump upstream of the discharge line siphon break - which is a pretty silly arrangement - and one you do not have anyway.
The point is, the only way a (back flow) siphon via the seawater discharge line could occur (either back into the holding tank or back into to the head itself) is if the seawater discharge were open and the wye valve were plumbed directly to seawater thus bypassing the holding tank. Unlikely - since you will probably never discharge overboard.
Based on your symptoms - check all tubes leading to the holding tank from one end to the other.
Charles
On the inlet side - Kloudie is right. Apologies for my lack of clarity -- do not put a siphon break in the intake to head-pump line. Rather - see to it you have one in the pump to bowl line so as to avoid a potential siphon threat.
As to that last West diagram - you achieve nothing with a siphon break in the seawater discharge line unless your wye valve can bypass the holding tank- thus running waste from the head direct to seawater. In fact, if you plumbed things the way the last West diagram shows it would be impossible to discharge waste from the tank directly to seawater at all unless you had dedicated discharge pump upstream of the discharge line siphon break - which is a pretty silly arrangement - and one you do not have anyway.
The point is, the only way a (back flow) siphon via the seawater discharge line could occur (either back into the holding tank or back into to the head itself) is if the seawater discharge were open and the wye valve were plumbed directly to seawater thus bypassing the holding tank. Unlikely - since you will probably never discharge overboard.
Based on your symptoms - check all tubes leading to the holding tank from one end to the other.
Charles
Last edited:
Please do not hook up a manual toilet to the freshwater system unless it is specifically designed for it. This WILL lead to contamination of your freshwater tank.
Peggy's book covers it well.
http://shop.odayowners.com/prod.php?53615
Last edited:
A quick point those of us that sail on salt or brackish water often have issues with Oder from the water in the bowl and marine organism that die there. To avoid that we never flush using the seawater line. If water is going to be tight we simply occasionally bring up a bucket of seawater to flush with. At the end of each day we use the hand shower to rinse down the bowl with fresh and pump drive and repeat. So long as the vent is clear Oder has not been a problem.
vented loop
This loop between the holding tank and the head is to prevent the sewage form running back into the head if the little flimsy valve in the head fails. when your head overflows on the floor with the contents of the tank it is really a bad day.
This loop between the holding tank and the head is to prevent the sewage form running back into the head if the little flimsy valve in the head fails. when your head overflows on the floor with the contents of the tank it is really a bad day.