Radio options and opinions

[Brad]

Here's a topic that is sure to raise some debate.I want to get a new (and my first) VHF radio to use when I launch next spring, in the $150 range. Do I go for a handheld or a fixed mount? My first thought was handheld: easier to use; don't need to run an antenna and cable; can keep it next to the helm so I can hear it. Now that I did some research, I found that life span of the NiCad batteries might be shortened by the way I will probably recharge the radio (that is, before it is fully discharged). The battery life is OK, but not great, and a fixed mount would use the boat's battery that I have to get anyway. So I'm also looking at fixed-mounts, which are a bit cheaper and have better range, but I'm concerned that if it is in the cabin I won't be able to hear and transmit at the helm without a RAM mic option - an added expense. Then there is the problem of running the cable up the mast to the antenna (I already have an antenna). So here are my questions: Which is more practical and why? Are my concerns about being able to easily hear the radio valid? If I go with fixed-mount, what are some ways folks have run the cable between the mast into the deck, and then back to the unit? I already have one two-conductor plug for the masthead light and don't want a bunch of wires sprouting from the deck to the mast. Thanks all.Brad A. O22 NYC

 

[Earl]

Batteries

I suggest starting with a handheld with Nickel Metal Hydride (NiMH) batteries. They last longer per charge and are not subject to memory degradation. Several are available for less than $150 on sale now, and more will be cheaper after Christmas. Then upgrade to a fixed VHF next time you go up the mast.

 

[Bob]

Think About Backup Systems

Hi Brad,Many of the hand held VHFs use rechargeable AA size and can be replaced if needed with one time AAs. Haven't use that feature, maintains charge over a weekend -original batteries still OK but have AA one times for VHF, GPS on board.I've been using a hand held for about 5 years and got it because the fix mount is too limited. Difficult to use when at the helm and hard to hear with the engine running.Recommend hand held as your first and for your next VHF consider another hand held (backup and for ship to tender / shore crew). If you decide on fix mount first - then also get a hand held as a backup. Fixed mount VHF antenna failure should be anticipated along with the total failure of boats electrical system. Hand held VHF is a good backup.

 

[Ben Allen]

Radio Quandry

Brad,Such a choice you have to make, might take several night of drinking copious amounts of booze to make that decision. Over time, I have ended up with both a fixed mount and a hand held. I use the fixed mount about 95% of the time, mostly because of the extended range. As far as use and hearing it, mine is mounted just inside the companion and to port, where it hangs above the quarter berth. That way, I can leave the mike outside in the cockpit when sailing. I also added a small waterproof speaker that plugs into the external speaker jack, and I have it mounted in the cockpit with velcro. The speaker is then placed inside the cabin at the end of the weekend. Whatever you decide to go with first, a VHF radio is a great addition to have on your vessel for safety.Ben AllenMontgomery, AL"Latte Dah"O'Day 26

 

[Justin - O'day Owners' Web]

Fixed mount

I carry both a fixed mount and a handheld radio and use both for different purposes. If I had to pick, though, I'd go for the fixed mount because of the increased range. If you need someone to bail you out you want to be heard.There are phyiscal traits about each that can zing you. If you lose the boats entire electrical system you have a problem (VHF radios should be wired directly to the battery or primary switch, with an inline fuse - not through the panel). On the other hand I only kn0w one person who ever dropped a fixed mount radio overboard - and he was in the process of installing it.For $150 I'd get a Standard Horizon Eclipse. I'd mount it to one side of the companionway and I'd ask Santa for a remote speaker to put in the cockpit.Justin - O'day Owners' Web