Most Catalina 30's tend to have a bit of a port list. What do you notice on yours, Jim?
Using the halyard presents some problems because of the above differences. I typically use the halyard as a plumb line at the gooseneck, this gives me both centered mast and rake, but if you have a natural list, that would be a problem. Get the boat level first.This will give you an approximate read--perhaps close enough. But bear in mind that your main halyard sheave is offset to one side.
The lower shrouds could be the culprit. If one side is looser than the other, excessive lateral bending on one tack over the other could loose you some efficiency, does she heel more easily on the slower tack? More camber aft due to a flexing mast could mean too much lateral lift at the expense of forward lift.
-Will (Dragonfly)