After seeing it mentioned a couple of times this summer, we visited Watmough Bay on Sept. 18th from Port Townsend. The weather had been a little uncertain for a couple of mostly 'South' sounders, but after only a slight mistake in the timing of our departure from Port Townsend, we managed to sail on a beautiful day from the Point Partridge buoy all the way up to Watmough Bay in about 7-8 kts of wind using our new code 0. What an awesome three hour sail for us!!!
As for Watmough Bay itself; a great place, compact, amazingly scenic, easy access to a nice gravel beach and a couple of hiking trails. We hiked the trail up to Chadwick Hill, which Washington Trails Assoc. lists as being 470 ft., some of the trail may be a bit difficult depending on your level of agility. We arrived on a Tuesday at about 12:30 - 13:00 and we were the second boat there. By sunset, there were a total of 10 boats anchored or grabbing one of three mooring buoys put there by someone... the following night we were in MUCH larger Reid Harbor on Stuart Island with only 10 boats. Watmough is listed as a favorite of one of Wagonner's contributors, but another guide book author that we like seems to hate the place. We were there on a a very calm day and night and loved it. Thanks for the recommendation!