My fix
I have the original Honda 9.9 on my 25.5, and didn't like how it flexed the transom where it is mounted. Obviously, a mid '80s four cycle is no feather. The original stainless bracket was mounted directly to the transom with no reinforcement either inside or outside. Bad design and/or execution by Hunter or its dealer.After removing the bracket, I discovered only minor cracking in the gelcoat around the four bolt holes through which the mounting bolts passed. From the inside, I was able to tell that the transom is cored with a relatively thick piece of plywood (1/2-5/8 inch). The problems were (1)that the stainless steel bracket lay directly next to the gelcoat on the transom, and (2) that the load created by the heavy outboard was not distributed over a wide enough area to prevent flex.I dealt with the two problems separately. First, I got a piece of black plastic from West Marine that it sells off the shelf and is intended to be used as a universal mounting plate for those swiveling chairs you find on power boats. Its dimensions are about 10 inches X 15 inches X 3/8 inches.(Cost: $14) It is very tough, won't rust, corrode, or need wood treating. I cut it so it is a little larger than the dimensions of my bracket where it meets the transom. I pre-drilled holes in the plastic to match those on the bracket and transom. This cushions the existing bracket from the gelcoat. I ran a bead of 3M 4200 around the edge of the plastic on the transom side to seal the area from any moisture penetration.Next, I got a free scrap of 1/2 inch plywood from the local lumber yard and cut this so that it was about 12X12, some new (longer) ss carriage bolts, and large diameter washers. (cost: about $3) With a buddy, we aligned all the pieces from the outside in, tapped the new bolts in with a hammer, and then tightened the bolts down. This is a two person job as you need someone to hold a wrench on the nuts below while you ratchet the bolts from the outside. (cost: one six pack of micro-brew) This spread the load from the outboard over a greater surface area, eliminating the flex. I check that the nuts are tight periodically. So far, no problems.You can buy new poly brackets that will spread the load for something over $100. You will need to seal your old holes in the transom and drill new ones for the new bracket. For $25 I'm happy with the fix I employed. Didn't have to line up and drill new holes in that expensive fibreglass, and more money for the micro-brews. This summer I was very pleased I had made the fix after returning from our annual cruise in the San Juan Islands. The Straits of Juan De Fuca were very lumpy and the motor was on causing it to get torqued around for about two hours. No problems. Good luck to you, and do take care of this problem.Scott