Tax dollars at work.
I had similar experience in Ohio. I moved from Vermont, where rowboats and canoes are not registered!(I love Vermont!) Ohio registers EVERYTHING (Taxes!). So, I show up with a used Old Town, no registration, no title and received conflicting non-helpful stories from Ohio BMV, Ohio Watercraft Division, Coast Guard Auxillary, County Registrar, etc. Finally found an "mature" licensed Ohio boat dealer who informed me that he could simply create a magical obscure affadavit of ownership if I raised my right hand and swore to him that it really was my boat! Seriously! He gave me the paper, charged me $1.50 fee and I was off to the BMV to register my canoe. Seems it happens all the time to dealers--people trade old boats, etc. without paperwork, so there has to be a mechanism to create a new regis/title. So, my advice, keep asking-where there is a will, there is a way. Also, consider registration in Vermont, if you know someone who has address there, as the folks in Vermont are truly helpful in these types of situations, although you might have to go to Montpelier to get it done. Good Luck.