Steve Dashew's.........
Steve Dashew's experiences with heavy displacement boats in hurricanes wouldnt apply to 99% of us here. For smaller boats that are not heavy displacement, an all anchor rode would probably weigh too much in the bow area. On many of the less expensive production boats, if you were anchored in a really bad thunderstorm (which is not unusual) with all the wind and stuff, a dacron or chain rode, without stretch (shock absorption), might just rip your cleat off or possibly break your small bow sprit. As for me, I'll stick to 3 strand nylon with about 20 ft of chain and go one size larger on the rope than the West Marine catalog recommends. To get back to the originaal question.....age is not a factor as wear and tare are. Keep in mind that we are talking good marine grade nylon, not discount house ( Home Depot) rope. Good reputable marine grade nylon is resistant to sunlight, diesel and gasoline spills. Nylon is relatively easy to inspect and looks are not really deceiving. First, if a nylon rope has been stresses -stretched- to its upper limits, it will be very stiff. This is due partly to the heat build-up from friction when stretching, the fibers have somewhat welded themselves together at a microscopic level and also the shape of the rope has been distorted. Next, look for the obvious signs of rope burn. This happens when way way over stressed. It is usually noticed around turning points such as on cleating areas or other attaching points. Then lastly, fraying from abrasion will be easily noticed.Use eye splices and stainless steel thimbles wherever you can.Chafe protection is of the utmost importance. Tony B